MovieChat Forums > New York, New York (1977) Discussion > UNLIKEABLE FILM WITH UNLIKEABLE CHARACTE...

UNLIKEABLE FILM WITH UNLIKEABLE CHARACTERS


I SUPPOSE MY THREAD TITLE SAYS IT ALL. BUT IT WAS GOOD TO SEE LIONEL STANDING IN AN UNTYPICAL ROLE. I WANTED TO SHOUT 'CUT' ON TOO MANY OCCASIONS. AND MINNELLI IRRITIATED BEYOND BELIEF. NO WONDER JIMMY DUMPED HER. AND LIZA LOOKED VERY OVERRIPE WITH WAY TOO MUCH MAKE UP. A BIT LIKE A DRAG QUEEN - WHICH MAY EXPLAIN HER POPULARITY IN SOME QUARTERS. THE WHOLE FILM WAS A RE-HASH OF 'A STAR IS BORN', WITHOUT THE CHARM, FEELING OR NUANCE OF CHARACTER. AND THERE REALLY ARE ONLY 2 SONGS OF NOTE IN THE WHOLE FILM WHICH WENT ON INTERMINABLY.

SORRY, BUT I THINK THAT THIS MAMMOTH OF A FILM PROVED THAT LIZA WAS BRILLIANTLY DIRECTED IN CABARET AND THAT SHE WAS A ONE NOTE PERFORMER. AND LIKE MAMMOTHS SHE IS NOW PRETTY MUCH EXTINCT.

reply

TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK.

reply

WELL, THIS IS NOT ONE OF MY FAVES PICTURES, BUT I DISAGREE WITH YOU. THIS MOVIE HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH THE BORING (if you refer to 1937's version, I've never seen the one with Judy Garland)"A STAR IS BORN"

reply

Jimmy was irritating and unlikeable. Francine was just irritating. She looked a chimp mimicking Jimmy's repetitive jumpy and abrupt half-wit sentences.

reply