MovieChat Forums > MacArthur (1977) Discussion > looked like a TV movie

looked like a TV movie


Even with HD, MacArthur "looks like" an inexpensively made-for-TV movie. BAD decision not to go to the actual locations. B.A.D. And "unfortunately" the General was never as close to combat and "action" as was GC Scott's Patton. Widescreen, epic format fits Patton to a "T". But even with a large visual field, MacArthur never gets us close enough to "the action" to justify its attempt at being a war epic. Yes: like Patton, MacArthur is meant to be received as a character study, BUT there's just something missing in MacArthur - which probably _should_ have been filmed as a TV movie or miniseries.

reply

I recently saw "MacArthur" again, this time in HDTV. I had always thought it was a made-for-TV movie because of its cheap production values, and was surprised to learn, on Wikipedia, it was a theatrical movie . The battle scenes looked low rent and phony, with soldiers dressed in just-washed uniforms, bereft of any combat gear except their rifles; unconvincing enemy machinegun fire and mortar explosions, and terrible action choreography which was obviously filmed in Malibu. The interior shots all looked like movie studios.

Most of the shots were medium or close-up, lacking long shots that established a sense of place, a sense of location, especially in the foreign and battle scenes.

I thought the script was okay, showing MacArthur as a great soldier with flaws, as was Patton and most other influential men. "Patton" looks like an expensive movie, given the film technology of the time, but "MacArthur" had that TV look, which is unfortunate, as location scenery, attention to battle scenes, and long camera shots could have added realism which would have made "MacArthur" a far better movie, doing justice to the stature and historical importance of Douglas MacArthur.

reply

Yeah. I wish Peck had analyzed the production values, esp. non-location shooting, before he agreed to take the role. But I guess actors can't be that fussy about every film they shoot ...

reply