My opinion is there's too many books on the subject - usually done by Clash fans who are bigger fans of so-called "punk music" than punk itself, since they can study it and form intellectual opinions on it! I've yet to see one of these books that was worth bothering with since mostly they're just overpriced lists - something you can get off an internet blog for free.
There's never been an especially good punk movie because anyone who actually was punk can never agree on what punk actually is. Punk is the scene itself, or even the movement if you want to make it important. And anyone who's ever been in a "scene" has personalized it in their head. Again, no one's is the same so no one's vision of it will be correct to anybody but the person who made it.
Decline of Western Civilization was criticized because it almost seems like Penelope grabbed the biggest idiots out of L.A. to make the movie. But it's real punks in a real scene - warts and all. Out of this came Suburbia - which I believe became an almost unofficial guidebook to punks in the late 80's for style, even though the movie was done in 1984! And finally, Another State of Mind, much like Decline of Western Civilization, showcased several real scenes, warts and all. With these three, you got to see the scenes (particularly L.A.) that influenced others at the time, especially in America. People at the time made fun of these movies, but they liked them all the same.
Unfortunately, there's even less on the UK front - you have Jubilee, Sid and Nancy, etc., but I think they tend to make punk look a lot better than it really was! Although I think Jubilee was the most fun of all the punk movies at the time - it may not have been a perfect eye into the punk scene, but who cares!
reply
share