Tell me the ending


I would appreciate any one who could tell me the last 20-30 mins of the movie. Honestly I wanted to like it and wanted to sit down through the whole thing but never could get into it. I got it from Netflix in March and took until now to even get 2/3 the way through! I tried to watch it last night and fell asleep after he talks to his mom in the rest home. I ended up returning to netflix this morning as that I just want to finally get a new movie in it's place and that someone out there might want to rent it and I felt bad hording it.

I thank anyone that is willing to be me a brief synopsis!

reply

[deleted]

Okay, you've explained literally what happens on the screen and in dialogue, but that's not enough with this film. You would have to do a lot of work on your own to figure out what really happened, as it's not really all there in the film. I haven't done this, but I can point to a few intriguing moments that I'll try to fill in. For one, why is it so crucial for the detective to get revenge on the pool hall criminal who killed the policeman early in the film? That cop was killed because he was corrupt, and it didn't seem like he was all that close with the protagonist anyway. For another, when his wife asks his girlfriend "What kind of fear is that?" regarding his apprehension to having a child, it seems like an important question, but it's left unanswered. So what kind of fear is that?

The final scene is interesting in that it's a satisfying ending without really making any logical sense at all. Which homicide is the detective under arrest for? The one where he stared into the eyes of a man before that man slit his own throat, or the one where he fled a self-destructing building that buried a mysterious glowing man? He wouldn't be convicted for either, but I'm guessing it's the second one. You are incorrect that he shoots the man, he just points the gun at him before it's knocked out of his hands. I suspect Cohen means to imply that leaving his gun at the scene of the crime incriminates him, but he never makes anything of that.

Okay, so he's arrested for that second homicide. But what would the trial for that crime be like? "Did you or did you not telepathically will the tenement building to self destruct and kill this man?" "Yes, your honor, God told me to." It's nonsense.

And yet, the last shot of him taking responsibility, in a way, for killing the Antichrist figure is strangely satisfying. Here's a man who assumes responsibility for all the sins of a city, both supernatural (series of linked but unmotivated killings) and petty (a dope dealer killing a crooked cop) and he achieves a kind of grace from it. I think Cohen wanted to end the movie with this image, but didn't bother to justify it. It's an effective conclusion: that ironic last line, "God told me to," repeated for emphasis and followed by the confrontational image (breaking the fourth wall) of a man who rights the wrongs of society, accepting his punishment and not asking to be understood. This significance is somewhat palpable in the film, but Cohen doesn't do the real work to get us there. We see the character change from a man who won't reveal himself to his girlfriend, who doesn't want to produce a son with his wife, who is an outcast at his job into a Christ-figure giving himself up for the betterment of the world, but this arc is not really sketched out in a way we could care about.

The film doesn't make sense, but it's not garbage.

reply

[deleted]

Yes, back in 2009, that's what the OP was asking for. I'm not skilled at writing synopses, but the OP hadn't gotten a reply in months, so I did the duty. Bear in mind I wasn't writing a critical review for the AFI. If I'd known you'd come along in 1.5 years, I might have deferred & let you do the honors.

Hey, I wasn't hating on your post. I was just saying that a strict recounting of the events on the screen doesn't really tell you what happened in the ending. I don't think it's bad form to bump up an old thread if you want to add to it. I wasn't so much responding to your post as I was riffing off of it.

It's explicitly stated that he was under arrest for the murder of Bernard Phillips (AKA: "mysterious glowing man").

Ah! You're right. I didn't believe you and I just pulled out my DVD and checked. One of those very low lines of dialogue.

reply

[deleted]

You know, I just got the Blue Underground disc as a gift and I didn't notice there was a commentary track. I'm on here speculating about the movie - maybe I should give him a shot to explain what he was doing. I think I'll give it a listen later today.

reply

Why would anyone waste their time to narrate the ending to the lazy-assed OP, who never returned to this thread? I mean, c'mon!

reply

Why would anyone waste their time to narrate the ending to the lazy-assed OP, who never returned to this thread? I mean, c'mon!


Because God told them to?



reply

😄 👍

reply

😅😆

reply