MovieChat Forums > 3 Women (1977) Discussion > Significance of the Use of Coca-Cola?

Significance of the Use of Coca-Cola?


A lot of people have commented on the water in the film, its use as a symbol of fertility as well as consciousness, but no one has pointed out how this water appears symbolically with relation to the omnipresence of Coca-Cola in the film. We see Coca-Cola at the hospital, at the apartment complex, and at the bar, and in the climactic and cryptic final scene it is a Coca-Cola delivery man who seems "duped" by the women who may have murdered the Man seducing them all, Edgar. Might the Coca-Cola represent the impurification of the waters of the womb with the phallocentric gods of carbonation, caffeine, and caramel color?

Sure, it might be just advertising, but I have the feeling every frame of this film was considered and reasoned and bears intricate study.

reply

As everyone knows already from Thieves Like Us, Altman used to be the main ad man for Coca Cola...



"facts are stupid things" - Ronald Reagan

reply

The plot thickens. A Pepsi machine is center-screen at the bus depot when Milli picks up Pinky's parents.

reply

Sadly, yes very sadly its about the money, not about any deeper meaning. So better buy some COCA COLA.

reply

Wow. I had no idea that such aggressive produce placement was happening during the 70's...especially in such an non-commercial style film.

I suddenly feel a little less dirty about my love for Terminator 2, even with all the ridiculous Pepsi product placement.

reply

...I have the feeling every frame of this film was considered and reasoned and bears intricate study.
________________
😄 Don't read more into something that need not be there. The film unfolded fluidly and also appeared spontaneous to me, which all gelled together without any unnecessary pretentions. The Coke thing was product placement only.

Exorcist: Christ's power compels you. Cast out, unclean spirit.
Destinata:💩

reply

With all due respect, I think you Altman-heads have tiny brains riddled by denial and cannot handle the paradigm shift I was threatening almost 3 years ago. You incredulously shoot down my point on the basis of a drilling back to authorial intentions, and finding no realistic basis -- however, this film began as Robert Altman's dream, and so thus the unconscious should be first and foremost, "The Culprit" we hold accountable ... and what might Freud say if he were here today to observe this internet-hosted Altman-ian symposium? Far from "A coke machine is sometimes only a coke machine" I believe he'd say something more like -- "Always be suspicious when one says something is not to be considered relevant, and especially in an act of polymorphous perversity such as a work of cinema, therein is the intervention of the rational censor to repress a tendency in the unconscious most apparent, dear boy."

The same man, the same brain, the same body who cashed a check from the Coca-Cola Company for advert work also had a dream vision of this film prior to shooting it. And might that dream, that meditation on identity and intra-feminine relationship, be also a upturning of the phallocentric mercantilism from which Altman The Artist emerged on behalf of the unconscious mind? A "watering down" of the rivers of Coca Cola Altman floated into Hollywood on, much like Moses into Egypt -- using a keg of amniotic fluid, that of true maternal as well as artistic creation? A "cutting of the Coke" that was shooting up Altman's nose every day on set, so to speak?

I am sorry to make such an ad hominem rebuttal as to say you have "tiny brains" -- I do not intend to initiate a "flame war" or to "troll you" -- but perhaps that is just years of built up frustration talking, my irrational angst getting the best of me in a cultural landscape that has quite unjustly and self-destructively "struck the root of the trunk of its tree with its axe" in terms of psychoanalytic film theory and now relies on glib platitudes for film criticism bounded relentlessly by the imagined perimeter of authorial intent as well as neo-historicism. When will the individual artist get the coca-cola watered down by amniotic fluid that he or she so thirsts for and deserves, the unique credibility that has us look deeper than what even might be intended consciously by a creator such as Altman?






reply

Hogwash, swilled down with a symbiotic Coke analogy. 😄

Exorcist: Christ's power compels you. Cast out, unclean spirit.
Destinata:💩

reply

Ok, got the coke-cola. Now what substance did you take when you wrote about the coca-cola?

reply