MovieChat Forums > The Pallisers Discussion > Some flies in the ointment (SPOILERS)

Some flies in the ointment (SPOILERS)


I am watching this for the first time as I missed it back in 1974. I am enjoying it mostly - but I do have a few criticisms. The acting on the whole is good - apart from the overdone scenes with Sonia Dresdel and Fabia Drake. I also found June Whitfield lacking - she is not really a dramatic actress and her facial expressions were sometimes overdone to the point of pantomime - the same can be said for Sarah Badel. Jo Kendall was unconvincing in virtually every scene she appeared in. Philip Latham and Susan Hampshire carried it all off superbly.
I found some of the scenes puzzling - what was the source of Plantagenet's rage for example when his son had a bad report. There seemed no reason for that at all. And when Lady Laura told Phinn that she would love him as a sister and that he must get married and she would love his wife also - then when he did she said that he had killed her and she never wanted to see him again.
The coincidence of the coat (regarding Bonteens assailant) was a bit hard to take as well - as was the overdone bribery scene with Emilius's landlady and Mrs Max.
I also found it strange that Glencora should tell Plantagenet that she knew he had never loved her when in fact he had told her years before when he saved her lover from ruin.
I have six episodes left - and it will be missed when it is over notwithstanding the above.

reply

I was in my mid teens when I first saw it here in the US in the later 1970s and I was enthralled. It led me to read 15 or 16 of Trollope's novels. Yes, I know I have 30-40 more to go, but there are other authors out there also. I see you are not a fan of the woman who played Lizzie Eustace (Sarah Badel), but the book's character is also over the top, as is the story itself. To the point that some fans of the books don't really think that her story fits in very well with the others in the series.

Anyway, it's pretty typical of its time in terms of the acting and production values. Lots of overacting and lots of staginess. If you watch any other period dramas from that period, you'll see what I mean.


http://currentscene.wordpress.com

reply

Thank you for your reply. I agree that it is a product of its time- and I make allowances for that - I am still enjoying it and will watch it to it's conclusion. It's so nice not to have tinkling music across dialogue and no sex scenes or overdone violence !!!

reply

If nothing else, the level volume is great so I don't have to keep switching the controls. Nice subdued backstabbing and subterfuge.

reply

Thank you for your response. I have just watched the last episode (sob sob !!) and I shall miss this series. Never mind - you never know - Susan Hampshire may pop up again in the original "Forsyte Saga" if we are lucky - along with the excellent and much missed Eric Porter.

reply

I'm not sure whether it's true or not, but I have a vague feeling that I was rushing back from Sunday night in the launderette in Southsea in the 1960s to watch The Forsyte Saga. I think I might have been joking while my undies were spinning.

reply

Such was the power of Irene !!

reply