MovieChat Forums > Carrie (1976) Discussion > over-acting of the mom turned it into co...

over-acting of the mom turned it into comedy instead of horror


it could have been a great horror film but the over-acting of the mom turned all those scenes into comedy

reply

Let me guess, you think the remake is much better than this one.

reply

I didn't watch the remake yet. just watched the original and I think a remake might be a good idea in this case (and usually I hate remake)
because I do see the potential for improvement in some places.

I'll watch the remake soon and will let you know what I thought of it

reply

Yeah, watch it and come back. To me, the remake is horrible.

reply

just watched the remake. indeed horrible.

what the hell happened to movie making??

did IQs suddenly drop in Hollywood?

why does every single remake suck so much.

it's just sad because it's such a missed opportunity of failing to improve the source material but instead they always make it much worse.


but I have to say that the actress who played the mom was better in the remake, but pretty much all the other characters were much worse. (especially the coach who was the best one in the original and the worst one in the remake)

carrie herself is totally unbelievable as the abused loner type in the remake unlike the original.

in terms of visual effects they went so over the top in the remake i felt like watching a star wars movie.
often times less is better.

turning her into a flying superman combined with emperor palpatine waving hands to kill everyone one by one was far worse than the original prom scene which (although i thought was a little lacking) was so much better than this over-the-top mess which felt like a darth vader wet dream more than a horror movie.




reply

A lot of people were turned off by her performance, but then a lot of people love her performance. I admit I wasn't a fan of her when I first saw this in 1978 and I even kind of hated Sissy Spacek as Carrie but that's because she played the role so well as a strange ugly girl. Same for the mother. She played an unlikeable character and she was so convincing at it.

reply

I actually preferred Piper Laurie's performance over Julianne Moore's. Which is weird because I am such a fan of Moore. But I felt her performance was so subdued. She whispered most of her lines, and came off as the frail and weak one, when that should have been Carrie.

Piper's overacting is exactly what is needed in the role. She is supposed to come off as this overbearing, religious fanatic, and I think pulled it off quite convincingly.

reply

Actually, one recent remake - Peter Jackson's redo of "King Kong" - was first rate. "Casino Royale" (with Daniel Craig) wasn't bad, either.

reply

"They're all gonna laugh at you!!!"

And her orgasmic moaning as she was dying...

reply

I think that the film throughout is pretty comedic. The whole concept of Carrie (teenage girl with psychic powers slaughters an entire town after being doused in pig blood at the prom) has an over-the-top ridiculousness to it, bordering on campness. De Palma's great achievement was to recognise and tap into that vein of the book and to give the film a shrieking, hysterical atmosphere rather than playing it straight.

I recall that Piper Laurie herself has said that she regarded the film as a dark comedy. And I know Quentin Tarantino has called it "hysterical" (as in funny) in an interview somewhere.

reply

I actually like how over-the-top her performance was. She was so absolutely crazy and I think that's how the character needs to be. It makes her seem scarier and more dangerous. Strangely enough I even sympathized with her. She just saw the world as a dark, evil place and in her own way she wanted to protect her daughter from it. I can understand that. She just went about doing it in the wrong way.

reply

I didn't feel that Margaret really wanted to keep her daughter safe.
She wanted Carrie ALL to herself, for one. Margaret deliberately dressed her daughter like a dork so she would be ostracized.

Margaret also, judging by her comments to Carrie at the end, always hated her for being a constant reminder of her own *sin*.
Add to that fact that Carrie had *devil powers* & that she refused to renounce them....then wanted to leave her and make her own life....only added to the situation.




I'd say this cloud is Cumulo Nimbus.
Didn't he discover America?
Penfold, shush.

reply

[deleted]

you have never seen evangelists or anyone else who loves their religion too much, have you.

this is seriously how they behave.

Ma White did not over act at all... over RE act maybe, but this is how her character was written.


Steven King just wanted the world to see just how hysterical and laughably pathetic these evangelists/'lovemyreligion' are. and rightfully so. they are pathetic and laughable. how can they NOT be?

Oh God. Fortune vomits on my eiderdown once more.

reply

Piper Laurie did not audition for the role of Margaret White. After winning an Oscar for her performance in the 1961 film THE HUSTLER, Laurie retired from show business. An executive at United Artists was a fan, and urged DePalma to try to get her for the role of Margaret. Laurie had then-recently made the decision to return to acting -- she had just filmed the PBS original film "A Woman's Rebel" -- but when she was sent the script for "Carrie," she initially passed on it because it seemed to be a bland role. A re-reading and a meeting with DePalma swayed her opinion -- she concluded that there was an element of outrageous black humor to the film --so she accepted the part. CARRIE won her another Oscar nomination, she resumed her acting career and has continued to appear in films and on television ever since.


Source: Somewhere on the interenet https://sites.google.com/site/cultoddities/home/carrie/carrie-1976/backstory

reply

You are utterly and completely alone in this opinion. Piper Laurie is a force to be reckoned with. Always has been.

We've met before, haven't we?

reply