MovieChat Forums > I, Claudius (1977) Discussion > Rewatching -- Makes Me Realize How Good ...

Rewatching -- Makes Me Realize How Good It Still Stands Up versus Today


It really struck me how well this holds up in writing and acting even almost 40 years later. Especially given such "blockbusters" as Downton Abbey and Game of Thrones -- which I also enjoy. But how I Claudius could get over such horrible scenes as would be shown in (for example) Game of Thrones without just getting bogged down in the graphic bloody violence. The scenes of Claudius' mother Antonia starving her daughter Lavilla; or the dinner where the Senator's wife recounts how she saved her daughter from being raped by Tiberius by taking her place -- then committing suicide at the dinner, etc. More horror conveyed than the "Red Wedding" of GoT without being distracted by special effects and graphic violence.

reply

I think people who think "I, Claudius" was too stagey-looking are people who haven't seen many stage plays. Maybe they have a problem with imagination. But then many of them were never exposed to productions that weren't full of blood and guts and graphic stuff.

I thought "I, Claudius" was superb when I first saw it in the 70s. Wonderful cast, absolutely top-notch writing. More than 30 years later, I can still remember so many scenes and quotes.

reply

Not only is it one of the best series of all time, it is quietly is gaining a reputation as such. Martin himself, the author of Game of Thrones, said that remaking I, Claudius would be like trying to redo Gone With the Wind. What higher praise could you give a television production? It directly inspired the makers of The Sopranos and Dynasty and Rome, and clearly has major influences on today's popular serialized political dramas. When I met Oliver Stone last month and asked if he would ever try to make a filmed version, his answer was "It has already been made."

reply

I'm watching the series for the first time at the age of 44! just finished 'a god in Colchester.'
how on Earth are they going to top that? Messalina's final scene actually made me gasp... I think that is the most powerful thing I have ever seen on a TV series.
felt like I was losing me own noggin!!!
greatest drama of all time?

reply