MovieChat Forums > I, Claudius (1977) Discussion > Sian Phillips Is Stupendous in This

Sian Phillips Is Stupendous in This


How great is Sian Phillips as the venomous Livia? I found it interesting to read that at first, she had a hard time getting a grip on the role, trying to make the first Roman empress more sympathetic and to figure out how to humanize her wickedness. The director then suggested that she relish the evilness and play the role like Cruella De Ville. The result might be one of the most fiendishly confident performances of all time.

She evolves believably over several episodes from a haughty young beauty to a jaded and disappointed old woman. Throughout the series, she commits acts of astounding cruelty. Yet somehow, her wit, her dignity, and her regal bearing make her a villain you almost root for. She can be alternately charming and manipulative (in her scene when she tricks the chief Vestal), sarcastic and menacing (when she interacts with Plautius and Livilla), and ruthless and bullying (during her pep talk with the gladiators). She anchors the first half of the narrative, and her presence is so palpable that even in her absence, her memory dominates later episodes; indeed, as a whole, the miniseries is as much about her as it is about Claudius.

How wonderful that Sian won the BAFTA award that year--I wish I could find the footage online. To me, her performance ranks as the third greatest female acting turn of all time, just behind Vivien Leigh's Southern diptych.

reply

Agreed, Her performance is one for the ages.
Livia's character believed that everything she did was "for the good of Rome" . Sian was able to convey this and thus
make her performance credible as well as powerful.

reply

"Oh, I care very much whether he live or dies."

"You're all scum and you know it."

"Don't touch the figs."

"Go on playing the fool, Claudius."


I agree with your entire post. Every actress in the English-speaking world must have been envying her this role and this performance.

In the book after her death Claudius tells his readers that while he waited eagerly for her death he would have sacrificed peacocks to get her back when Tiberius began going off the deep end. I think most of the audience would have agreed.



The Fabio Principle: Puffy shirts look best on men who look even better without them.

reply

After all she had done - the evil bitch - she still managed to elicit sympathy from me when she cried "He won't make me a goddess!"

reply

I agree despite the fact that Livia's evil was with all mental faculties intact while Caligula's was at least somewhat fueled by madness.

Wasn't it also interesting and supremely ironic when Claudius talks about making her a goddess at last and Messalina naively talks about how proud the God Augustus would be to present her to the other gods.



The Fabio Principle: Puffy shirts look best on men who look even better without them.

reply

I don't believe that she was even nominated for an Emmy.

reply

I don't know if PBS shows got much love from the Emmys back then. Phillips deserved all the accolades she could get. She was wonderful. The actress on Penny Dreadful who plays Mme. Kali seems to base her performance on Phillips' portrayal of Livia.

reply

She's the only thing I really enjoyed about the pilot :/

Death Awaits (Horror forum)
http://w11.zetaboards.com/Death_Awaits/index/

reply

She had to be my favorite aspect of the whole series. Truly a scary and menacing character, and yet still believable as a human being and even somehow managing to still be sympathetic as she was dying after all she had done. It was an incredible performance, one of the best i've ever seen.

The people, and the people alone, are the motive force in the making of history.
-Mao Zedong

reply

I felt sorry for her, now old and helpless, and believing that she was doomed to suffer eternal torments after her death, because Caligula had denied her the Goddess Pass. Great actress.

reply

One of the greatest TV villains.

Forget it Jake. It's Chinatown.

reply

It's funny that I can watch this over and over and every time after she dies when some female kills someone here, all I can think of is "Livia did it first, and she was much more clever at it". It's all in the acting. The worst was Claudius's wife in the end. By this time, it's been overdone. In Sian's performance, there's both humor and regret, and that makes it much more intriguing.

"Great theater makes you smile. Outstanding theater may make you weep."

reply

I couldn't agree more. I think everyone in the cast did a superb job but Sian gives a standout performance. Livia is ice cold and cunning, Sian portrays those aspects of Livia so well.

Her performance is all in her eyes and it's fascinating to watch her. Livia is always alert and watching what's going on around her. One of the greatest screen villains for sure.



Go to bed Frank or this is going to get ugly .

reply

I'm getting ready to order a movie from the 1950's called "Nero's Mistress" where Gloria Swanson plays the role of Aggrapina, Claudius's last wife, and Nero's mother. I'm trying to find several rare movies made during that time about Messalina, particularly one starring Maria Felix. I find this whole subject (particularly the family dynamics) fascinating.

"Great theater makes you smile. Outstanding theater may make you weep."

reply

She's the Alexis Carrington of Ancient Rome! I'm glad she won an award for her role, she and Derek Jacobi fully deserved their BAFTAs!

reply