Nice Yakuza?


The movie - but more so the making of featurette 'Promises to keep' (included on the current DVD release)- makes out that the Yakuza are men or honour who follow a samurai type code and only hurt their own. This is baloney and it was the case back in the 70s.

The Yakuza have always been involved in extortion, murder, fraud, sexual slavery, prostitution, and pornography including child pornography. Its a myth that they don't hurt ordinary people just because the Japanese media and police cover up their involvement in crimes. They are very good at what they do and that includes intimidating victims, witnesses, journalists and the authorities - and bribing officials to 'go blind'. Have a read of TOKYO VICE by Jake Adelstein, an American who worked as a journalist in Japan until the Yakuza threatened him and his family.

The Yakuza is a great little film but as a true portrayal of the yakuza its as inaccurate as the Godfather is of the mafia.

...now I do it just to watch their f----n' expression change.

reply

Know somebody studying Japanese in college and I asked if they touched upon Japan's Yakuza. They said briefly, the professor giving the same relatively benign image you reference, nice to see the falsehood continue to be perpetuated in academia. Will look for the book Tokyo Vice, thanks.

reply

I don't think the film paints the Yakuza in a positive light, since Tanner's daughter was kidnapped, and was going to be butchered, if he didn't get the guns for Tono. The "finger cutting" was done because of family obligations (Ken and his brother because of the "spider" nephew, and Ken and Kilmer because of Ken's wife and daughter). Ken left the lifestyle and didn't want to return to it. They're portrayed as corrupt killers and kidnappers, accurately.



---------------------------------

Machete don't text

reply

I once asked my Japanese girlfriend if Yakuza would give me problems if I somehow crossed paths with them.  I had heard that Yakuza are lenient with gaijin because we are perceived as ignorant to their culture, but she ominously shook her head and warned me to cross the street should I see them coming my way.  She may have been exaggerating but I heeded the advice.

reply

The Yakuza are linked to right-wing/nationalist political parties, and can be seen as security details at their rallies. I can't imagine they would be lenient with gaijin. The Japanese on the whole are not exactly foreigner-friendly so I don't expect their crims to be. I've been to Japan, have seen the Yakuza from a distance and wouldn't want to mix it with them.

You never know them all.

reply

There is a long tradition of Yakuza fiction in Japan (prose, manga, film, drama, etc..) that perpetuate the stereotype of the Yakuza as protectors of the underclasses, in a samurai-like tradition. Like many things, there may be an element of truth at the ehart; but, the reality is far different. just as the samurai were often not quite so noble and the code of bushido was more of an ideal than a reality, the roguish protectors wasn't the true nature of often vicious people. It's much like the gangster films and novels of America (and elsewhere) where we see codes of honor and the like. These are predators, pure and simple, though even predators have complexities.

The Yakuza not only have been involved in right-wing politics; they also were/are silent partners in major Japanese corporations. In the Occupation and rebuilding era, they were the ones with money (through various source; mostly vice) and they have used that to influence many elements of Japanese society.

Fortunately, Ah keep mah feathers numbered for just such an emergency!

reply

Yes, it's similar to the false image of the benign politician as "public servant" here in America.

It serves several large forces to perpetuate it.

reply