what was the point of this?


meaningless.

reply

It's a mystery in the truest sense -- there's no easy answer. The point is that there is no explanation. Instead the movie focuses on the reactions of others to the mystery.

But, still, the viewer can't help but chew on the material and try to connect the dots; if not in regards to what actually happens to the missing females, at least concerning the film's message.

I think it means: The only way to escape the constraints/limitations/corruptions of a flawed society on Earth -- with the understanding that every society is flawed -- is to literally leave the Earth.

reply

confusing movie

reply

A friend of mine once gave me his account of seeing Hanging Rock for the first time. He said he couldn't get it out of his head afterward as he tried to make sense of what happened to those girls. Some people enjoy the mystery of it--the fact that it does not spell out what happened. It's like 2001 in that respect.

reply

i think some kind of hint would have made it better. was it meant to be supernatural or not. i have no idea.

reply

The film was an examination of the people left behind, their reactions and how Victorian society (with its latent suppressions) and culture shaped their response to the event. Commentary and character study I'd suggest. The girls disappearance is secondary, and relatively unimportant beyond what you see.

If you dig around a little, you'll find online what the author originally had in mind for the big reveal.

Prepare to be disappointed if you do.

reply

What's the point of "teasing" that? Can you just say it? Don't really feel like "digging around" if the info is readily available

reply

From Wikipedia:

"The chapter opens with Edith fleeing back to the picnic area while Miranda, Irma, and Marion push on. Each girl begins to experience dizziness and feel as if she is "being pulled from the inside out." A woman suddenly appears climbing the rock in her underwear, shouting "Through!", and then faints. This woman is not referenced by name and is apparently a stranger to the girls, yet the narration suggests she is Miss McCraw. Miranda loosens the woman's corset to help revive her. Afterwards, the girls remove their own corsets and throw them off the cliff. The recovered woman points out that the corsets appear to hover in mid-air as if stuck in time, and that they cast no shadows. She and the girls continue together. The girls then encounter what is described as "a hole in space", by which they physically enter a crack in the rock following a lizard; the unnamed woman transforms into a crab and disappears into the rock. Marion follows her, then Miranda, but when Irma's turn comes, a balanced boulder (the hanging rock) slowly tilts and blocks the way. The chapter ends with Irma 'tearing and beating at the gritty face on the boulder with her bare hands.'"

Almost comically bizarre, but in a way I would have preferred that ending on film. If you're gonna fabricate a fictional mystery, I'd appreciate a damn conclusion.

reply

Thanks, thats hilarious and I agree.

reply

I would tend to agree with you--it did seem rather meaningless. I've noticed other people alleging the film is some societal or cultural commentary but for me it doesn't work as such. Apart from the beautiful photography, the mystery was the only thing keeping the film interesting. For there to be absolutely no resolution in that regard was pretty weak.

reply

" I've noticed other people alleging the film is some societal or cultural commentary but for me it doesn't work as such. Apart from the beautiful photography, the mystery was the only thing keeping the film interesting."

After the first, maybe even second, viewing that was exactly true for me too. But over the years, now knowing what to expect (and not expect) from the film, I find the reactions and behavior of the townspeople come more into focus and I now fall into the category of people who feel the intention of the film was "some societal or cultural commentary" (and a rather good one at that). Without obsessing over the mystery of what happened to the girls I am free to focus on the characters that we DO see and that draws me in and makes me more appreciative of the film on the whole.

"For there to be absolutely no resolution in that regard was pretty weak."

I understand. For some films I feel that way too. For others I think "open-endedness" or "unknown conclusions" are perfectly desirable and actually preferred. But to each his/her own. Some people despise ambiguity in any form, others embrace it and the room allowed for imagination to flourish. I love the latter, as long as it is (forgive me) earned and not a gimmick.

reply

I appreciate the majority of your post, but your last paragraph is off-base. I have no problem with ambiguity. The ending of this film was not "ambiguous". It was non-existent. For a conclusion to be ambiguous, there has to be at least a few clues or suggestions (often vague or even contradictory) presented, allowing viewers to formulate their own plausible theories regarding the events of the film. There was none of that here. Ambiguity leaves room for interesting discussion. The (non)resolution of the mystery of Picnic at Hanging Rock does no such thing.

There are many great films with ambiguous endings: Blade Runner, The Shining, Taxi Driver, The Thing, etc.

Picnic at Hanging Rock is not comparable to them.

reply

Point taken and well explained.

Though I didn't intend to specifically place PAHR in the "ambiguous" category. Rather just making a broader point that films that don't resolve are often disdained by people who don't particularly care for such films. But "such films" are not one-size-fits-all to your point. Shall I say this film (and maybe others like it) have unresolved mysteries? Perhaps when speaking specifically about PAHG that would be more appropriate? Well, as I alluded in my previous post, I wasn't thrilled with the film the first viewing or two. I only revisited the film later on to see if I could tease out clues to suggest the fate of the girls. I couldn't. But I began to see the film in a different way and now find it both more acceptable and enjoyable.

reply

Fair enough. "Unresolved mystery" is definitely a more accurate description; I can get on board with that.

Maybe I'll give the film another shot sometime down the line to see if I can appreciate it any more, as you did. It'll probably be a while before I'll wanna take another crack at this one though, if I'm being honest.

reply

I enjoyed the eerie atmosphere of this film. It’s style is dated but it has a similar tone to films like The Virgin Suicides, The Blair Witch Project and the recent Yellowjackets series (which had potential in the early episodes but just dragged the story out too long.)

Not every plot has to have a resolution to tell a story. There are unsolved mysteries in the real world and this film explores the frustrations and hopelessness of never knowing the truth.

reply

Funny enough I was about to defend the film and respond but I took a moment to check the origin of the story/book that it was based on. As it turns out I had seen this film, many years ago, with belief that it was all based on a factual event as a result of a recommendation. It wasnt. Had I know that prior to seeing it I can imagine feeling the same way as you. As a matter of fact there is very little chance I would have watched it had I not thought it was based on a true event. If its based on a true story than its creepy and mysterious if not its just another fictional tale with a wholly unsatisfactory ending. Conclusion… You are correct sir! 🙂

reply

I rewatched it today, having seen it once when I was very young and been underwhelmed. Up until today I, too, had always believed this to be based on a true event. While I agree that knowing it is fiction diminishes it to a point, I was much more impressed by the film as a whole than first time around. I tend not to appreciate movies that offer no answer to the mystery - it too often comes across as lazy writing - but ‘Picnic at Hanging Rock’ has such a one-of-a-kind dreamlike atmosphere that the lack of closure, for me, somehow works to its advantage.

reply

i like to see movies have some kind of conclusion. i was disappointed with this one after putting off watching it for years.

reply

To show how a town reacts to a strange situation/event. Like those unsolved murder films where the policemen become obsessed with solving the case. The not knowing what's gone on. Certainly a frustrating first watch, if you go in with set expectations.

reply