MovieChat Forums > Overlord (1977) Discussion > Two possible inaccuracies in this film

Two possible inaccuracies in this film


Two possible inaccuracies in this film, the first being near the beginning when Tom played by Brian Stirner reports to the barracks. In the background you see a radiator. In Britain houses were not built with central heating as standard equipment until the mid 1970’s generally speaking & up to the early 1980’s it was still possible to find a newly built house with no heating system. I doubt very much that a British Army barracks in the 1940’s would have had anything more high tech than a trusty old paraffin heater.

The other inaccuracy is that Tom speaks with a middle class accent yet he is just an ordinary squaddie. With his sort of background you would have thought he would have been at least a junior ranking officer. The class system in modern Britain is almost gone but it is still very much alive & well in the Forces. In the 1940’s this would have been even more extreme.

reply

[deleted]

Can't comment on the radiators - you may or may not be right.

But I do know that there were plenty of middle-class - and even a few upper-class - soldiers in the British army ranks during WWII (and for some years afterward while National Service remained in place). Some of them conscripts, some volunteers who simply preferred it that way for reasons of their own.

Many may have subsequently undergone officer training and got promotion, but certainly not all.

Similarly, while working-class-born officers would have been an incredible rarity in the peacetime army, the wartime services were far more of a meritocracy, and some squaddies rose to relatively high rank simply through ability.

reply