MovieChat Forums > Nashville Discussion > The Target? - SPOILER ALERT!

The Target? - SPOILER ALERT!



I was watching Nashville for the umpteenth time and I saw something that made me question Kenny's target. He could have been targeting Barbara Jean or Connie White. Barbara Jean happened to be at the wrong place at the wrong time. Kenny wanted a very public place to assasinate, so he could get the attention he wanted. Because if he really wanted Barbara Jean dead, he had opportunity. The security everywhere seemed very lax. Scott Glenn's character was able to sneak by the security guard into her hospital room and spend the night and the nurse that comes in just "whatevers" the intrusion and goes about her business.

What gave me a hint of who the target is the scene at the Grand Old Opry. When Haven Hamilton announces that Barbara Jean will not be appearing, the Scott Glenn character - who is obsessed with Barbara Jean - gets up and leaves. Then the camera shows Kenny still seated and sipping his soda.

Just wondering.



I'm not into your passport picture, I just like your nose.

reply

The implication is that he's planning to shoot Walker, but something about Barbara Jean's performance causes him to snap and kill her instead.

"They ate Mummy! They burned Mummy and killed her and ate her!"

reply

My take has always been that he was going to shoot Walker, but watching Barbara Jean sing "My Idaho Home" triggered (no pun intended) a visceral response in him. In that one moment, she personified all that he hated -- family, love, purity, America, etc. Or perhaps it was a jealous rage, in that he had never experienced the family love captured in her song.

"When the legend becomes fact, print the legend."
... "The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance"

reply

I think the point is that the identity of the target wasn't important to the assassin as long as the target was celebrated. If his objective was political, he'd have waited for the prototype of Ross Perot. If he wanted to shoot exhibitors of crummy hair styles and lousy songs, Henry Gibson's character would have died. He shot at the people at the center of the stage. Through hurting someone famous, he became famous too.

It's absolutely chilling to watch this again. Like seeing a Mark David Chapman with even less focus.

reply

"Or perhaps it was a jealous rage, in that he had never experienced the family love captured in her song."

I think this is probably closest to whatever "truth" underlies his actions. Remember the heated phone conversation with his mother where he ends the call prematurely but fakes a codial "goodbye" in front of LA Joan, for her benefit.

He was obviously in Nashville, hovering around the Walker campaign and its activities, carrying his gun in the locked fiddle case, with the key on a chain around his neck, with a purpose or design. We can surmise that he had a plan to assassinate Walker, and that he was going to do so at Centennial Park that day, or continue to watch him in an ongoing plot to do so at some point in the near future. Something about Barbara Jean's song caused him to snap before he was ready to do so.

Although, I will say, on re-watching the film, there's a red herring there, where Kenny shows up at Barbara Jean's concert. The only thing I can conclude about that is that he was follong Del and Triplett, trying to get a location on Walker's whereabouts, maybe?

reply

I've never been completely convinced that Barbara Jean was his target either, primarily, because after Barbara Jean went down, he kept on shooting.

reply

My thoughts were that there were two things influencing his decision to shoot-
1) his anger that LA Jean had ditched her aunt's funeral led him to hate whatever had taken LA Jean away from the funeral, essentially the concert

2) his frustration with his situation- not being able to find what he came to Nashville for, his mom not supporting him

reply

You know, he was carrying that gun around in the fiddle case for a reason. The decision to shoot was not a spontaneous thing, though the identity of the target may have been. I believe Kenny - like Sueleen and Albuquerque and the rest - wanted to be famous.

"Who does this treachery?" I shout with bleeding hands

reply

I think Kenny shot Barbara Jean because of the way she was worshipped in this film. His assassination was a comment on the way the pursuit of fame and the famous take over our lives (exemplified by L.A. Joan leaving the funeral to watch a concert).

We'll see whose the filthiest person alive! We'll just see!

reply

Whats interesting about this is the idea of worshipping or being obsessed with a singer/star. I always assumed that Kenny killed her, because he was obsessed with her. But thats kind of counterintuitive when you think about it. Im just realizing how much of this notion is informed by the John Lennon murder. It is, I believe, the biggest reason we think that obsessed people might kill the person they are obsessed with.
So, considering that that had not happened yet, Im curious. In 1975, was it believeable that someone might kill a star that they were obsessed with. I mean its obviously somewhat believable, but is it consumable in movie as a believable plot point? I'm not sure.

reply

I always thought it was ironic one person became infamous and another person became famous due to the same event. I thought with Kenny, no one but him really knew or understood his delusional mindset. Everyone was living in their own little worlds and his was the most incomprehensible. It certainly made the quest for fame not seem as innocuous.

reply

Fame in America, like politics, abhors a vacuum. Kenny becomes infamous for killing Barbara Jean. The circumstance thrusts Albuquerque on to center stage where she ends up stealing the show, and by implication becomes a celebrity. One star dies, therefore another has to be born.

reply

[deleted]

Altman, in his commentary, said the target was Barbara Jean all along. I never heard what his idea of the motive was. My interpretation is it was a symbolic killing since Barbara Jean was an icon. Some ordinary guy with little to nothing going for him can rob the world of one of its treasures. The guy did it because he could and, in his deranged mind, not having a life of any consequence or meaning from his own view, he decided to ruin the lives of many by taking away someone who gave joy and hope to them.

The beauty of this film is it is open for interpretation. While Joan and Bob may have decided the target was Barbara Jean, someone may interpret it in a completely different way and that interpretation is as truthful as Bob's and Joan's. It is your perspective that counts.

Enriching ideas all around. Shows the power and profundity of a great cinematic experience. Thank you all.

reply