If your assertion were true that "animals have a keen sense of impending danger" with the implication that this is evidence the dog survived, then no predator would ever catch any prey and the entire food chain would collapse.
You missed one important point: My assumption is that Pippet didn’t go into the water after the last toss of the stick. He stayed on land where he was less vulnerable and where the danger lurking in the ocean couldn’t get to him.
Not every stalked/hunted animal gets killed. They use their natural defenses and their instincts to evade capture. If your premise is that this never works, then every “low on the food chain” species would be extinct due to its predators.
I assume, however, that such a simplistic statement is
not your premise, in which case we are back at the same point: the
possibility that Pippet survived. I’m not saying it’s a certainty, but it’s not beyond belief either, especially based on my assumption that Pippet avoided the water in the middle of the fetch game.
I guess we’ll have to agree to disagree: You’re in favour of one possibility while I’m in favour of the other.
reply
share