Where did Donny go?


I am watching this on youtube and after Revenge, Donny just isn't there. For those that don't remember, Donny arrived with Vic's old GF with the petrol tanker.

Is it ever explained?

And more generally, what is it with going into production and not having scripts worked out sufficiently in advance, or actors under contract to go forward, that we have to see recasting or characters illogically disappear? (Vic taking a gunshot to the face probably fooled no one.) I'd like to be able to say that, yeah, this is a 40 year old production and people were less professional, but this sort of thing still goes on today, and TV production was never inexpensive.

reply

OK, I got to Season 2 Episode 1 and in a cheap piece of expository narrative Paul tells us that 'Donny and Pete' died in the fire. Given that there is no Pete character in the story yet, altho I see from credits one does appear later, I assume this is a writing or acting error and that Paul meant to say 'Donny and Vic'.

This truly is crappy production standards and I won't be watching further episodes. How this rates 8 point something on imdb is mind boggling.

reply

In the novel, the man and boy who appear at the beginning of the episode Garlands War, ended up joining Abby's community. The boy's name was Peter, which led Abby to think it was her son.
So assuming these two moved to the Grange sometime between series 1 and 2, this would explain who "Pete" is.

reply

So the guy in the wheelchair died in the fire? I don't remember the names of the background character. What happened to the two elder women of the series that were in the last 5 or 6 episodes of series 1? The vanished too. The only person that was explained were the ones that died in the fire and Abby.

reply

Terry Scully (the original Vic) was ill - If I remember correctly, I read "mental breakdown" once. That's the only reason he was recast mid-series.

reply

I too hated the way characters would be introduced then just disappear or get killed offscreen because the writers either tired of them or the actors couldn't come back. Vic was a huge shame but understandable as the health issue was unexpected, but the others just annoy me. A certain longtime major character is so ignobly killed off (offscreen, even!) in season 2 that I was enraged!

However, the show is definitely worth taking the bad for the good.

Like Terry Nation's Blakes 7 (and the best of Doctor Who), Survivors is a product of its tome and place, when continuity was hardly considered, budgets were shoestring and the BBC either didn't care or actively hated their own program.

Also, all those shows are cult favourites justifiably for their best episodes, when the writing puts most modern shows to shame, and the acting is superb. While there will be rubbish episodes, laughable "effects" and slipshod continuity, there are also extremely powerful and effective stories. Modern viewers have expectations these old shows won't meet (pacing alone may put some younger viewers off!), but there can be no doubt that when these shows are at their best, they are incredible and deserving of their reputations.

For the record, Donny is confirmed dead after the fire (along with two female main cast and Vic). Pete puzzled me, as there was another minor character who joined but never appeared again with a different name, but later I learned that indeed the character could have been the boy who they met with his father in a previous episode... in the book, they joined the group rather than just passing them by as in the series.

reply