MovieChat Forums > Where the Red Fern Grows (1974) Discussion > Whoa!! *SPOILERS* 4 THOSE WHO HAVE NOT R...

Whoa!! *SPOILERS* 4 THOSE WHO HAVE NOT READ THE BOOK



*SPOILER*

We had to read this book last year 4 reading. When we got to the part where the boy dies when he gets stabbed we all sat there stunned 4 like 5 minutes! When the end came half the room was crying (includin me)One kid had to go out of the room he was just SO sad. WOW!


Umm... I think the book was sadder than the movie! In the movie uh.. Mabey it was because we already knew what was going to happen but....
Share ur thoughts!










Ha ha ha why r u wasting ur time?

reply

I read this in 6th grade. Nobody cried when Rubin got killed. We were all stunned though, some were disgusted too cause of the way the book explains it.

Listen to this: All through the book whenever Billy cried this one girl in the class would complain. She kept saying "What? He's crying again! Why's he crying now?" But when we got to the end and the dogs died we all looked over and saw her crying. Then some people laughed because she had been complaining about him being a crybaby then she cries herself. The teacher said "Is it ok for him to cry now?" 3 other people in the class cried. One of them tried to claim he had something in his eye. Yeah he did alright, tears. I didn't cry but I was really stunned. I couldn't believe what I was reading.

reply

Haha, Yeah everybody in my 6th grade class cried when the dogs died, but nobody except me seemed to care at all when Rubin died from getting an AXE shoved into his stomach.

Strange.
One plus two plus two plus one...

reply

The teacher said "Is it ok for him to cry now?"
Burn. That teacher pwned the smartass little bitch but good.

reply

have no heart or soul do you?

reply