The two older sistere's


I don't get why Mary call took over the family and did everything, even working at the cafeteria for free hot lunches and Devola didn't do crap, you think since she is the oldest she would run the family.It just bothered me how Devola would act like the younger kids.

reply

I agree. It was a bit frustrating watching Mary Call do all of the work while Devola acts as if she was the youngest but I really think that Devola was perhaps a bit slow in many ways and weak as well. Mary Call was very smart and strong and seemed to have much more self confidence than Devola so it would make sense that Mary Call had to take over I suppose.

Peace.
PCL

reply

Reading the book, one discovers that Devola is retarded. The movie softens her retardation, so that Stanton's character's obsession with her is not quite so grotesque, but we are still meant to understand that she is incompetent to lead the family.

reply

when i watched the movie i got that devola was a dreamer and the dad didn't beleive s could raise the kids. He said mary was gonna have to be like the father and devola the mother. She was more homemaker and i thought she had to be there in case someone went snooping around the house. also didn't she take care of the young sister?

reply

I find it interesting and sad as well that people don't notice the (behind the scenes) work of a woman. After reading these posts, I watched the movie again to see how it is that Devola doesn't "do crap." Actually, she does quite alot, although she is a more wife/mother figure while Mary Call has the toughness needed to deal with the snoopy neighbors situations etc. Like a husband and wife, the girls seem to compliment each other. What I observed was Devola cooking the meals, cleaning, taking care of Ima Dean and out wildcrafting and working with Mary Call and the two kids. I'd have to say it was really both Devola and Mary Call who were taking care of the family even though Mary Call had the stubborn, fiery, I'm in charge personality and Devola was more gentle and calm and patient, the perfect traits of a model wife and mother(homemaker). We see this in several scenes when she comments on Mary Call's snappish attitude with the two little ones, telling her to be more patient with Romey and also taking charge and taking the kids for a ride to get them calmed down. Romey and Ima Dean were just children and needed both Mary Call's firmness and directness and Devola's motherly gentleness and patience. In a very interesting way, it also seems that it is Devola who is more in charge then Mary Call, as it is Devola who keeps the peace. Not many sixteen/seventeen year olds would allow themselves to be ordered around by a hot tempered fourteen year old, but Devola never snaps back or fights with Mary Call. She handles these situations with the maturity and grace of a strong woman not an immature child. In this sense, although Mary Call feels "in charge" and in many ways, is, it is Devola who is truly in charge in many ways. While some people may interpret the scene as childishness, I myself like the scene where Devola chases the pig with Romey and Ima Dean. She is being a mother. The children work very hard and a few minutes of laughter and playfulness is good for them. Most mothers take time to play with their children. If one has read the book (as I have done), Devola does appear to be somewhat retarded or more accurately developmentally delayed in some areas, a "softening" of retardation is not what is portrayed in the movie. What we we see in the movie, is a relatively mature young woman who knows whats important and acts accordingly.

reply

Great post, pstlw3!! Thanks!!

reply

this set-up seems to follow the responsible, in charge second sister formula seen in Jo from Little women and Elizabeth from Pride and Prejudice. Why this is so popular in lit is beyond me.

"what is your major malfunction numbnuts?!!"

reply

If you had paid attention when watching the movie it was explained by Roy Luther that Devola took the mother's role four years ago. Mary Call is taking over the father's role.

All the kids except maybe little Ima did a lot more than what today's kids would do.

reply