MovieChat Forums > The Texas Chain Saw Massacre (1974) Discussion > The cook is their brother, not their fat...

The cook is their brother, not their father


I know that won't be news to some of you, but I'm usually met with derision when I say he's the brother of Leatherface and the hitchhiker. It seems like everyone thinks he's the father. I say no way. Here's why:

1. The hitchhiker mentions his brother worked at the slaughterhouse. There's no way he's talking about Leatherface. I mean, can you imagine Leatherface holding down a job? Sure, I can just picture him picking out his outfit for the job interview, wondering what face he's gonna wear to make a good impression.

Now forget for a moment that Leatherface was shown working at the slaughterhouse at the beginning of the sequel to the remake (that being TCM: The Beginning, of course). That, for me, has no meaning in regard to the original TCM. In TCM: The Beginning, while at the slaughterhouse, Leatherface just seems really creepy and intimidating, but someone who could still hold it together at work (at least until he's fired, that is). In the original, Leatherface is presented as an absolute mental defective who is prone to uncontrollable homicidal outbursts. The hitchhiker couldn't have meant that Leatherface was the brother who worked at the slaughterhouse.

2. If the cook was their father, why would he refer to his father as grandpa? Admittedly, lots of parents do that when mentioning their parents to their kids, just like a dad might call his wife "mom" in front of their kids, instead of by her name. In this case, the cook calls him grandpa because he is his grandfather.

3. Okay, I probably should've led with this, but in the book "The Texas Chain Saw Massacre Companion", on page 41, both Gunnar Hansen and Jim Siedow confirm that the cook was the eldest brother.



reply

The general pushback is usually, "So if the cook isn't the father, where is the father then??"

I don't know, but if I had to guess, I would say in his grave, or maybe in a pot of chili.

reply

In TEXAS CHAINSAW 3D he was the father, but in the first two films I always believed Drayton was the oldest brother. The mom appears in 3, at least I think she's the mom. But the father, as far as the first four movies are concerned, is probably dead.


http://www.freewebs.com/demonictoys/

reply

Oh wow, that totally slipped my mind about TC3D (didn't care for that one). Good point. That's a good example of how so many people think he's the father that then that's what he eventually became.



reply

LF and Hitchhiker look pretty inbred. Are you sure he's not both ? (ewww!)

reply

Ha ha! You might be on to something there, Anthony. It would certainly satisfy both those who think he's the dad and those who say he's the brother. But yeah, ewwwwww!



reply

Plus he said his brother makes good head cheese and its states hes the cook.

reply

[deleted]

How did the rumor that cook was their father get started in the first place?

I don't recall the original confirming how the "Old Man" was related to the others. It was TEXAS CHAINSAW 3D that came out and said he was the father.

The Hitchhiker mentions his brother and grandfather worked at the Slaughterhouse. I suppose you could assume he's referring to Leatherface, but I find it unlikely as Leatherface isn't the type to go out in public, despite what the Hewitt continuity showed us. And in TCM 2 Drayton says "taking care of my younger brothers," so I would say in the first two films he was the oldest brother.


http://www.freewebs.com/demonictoys/

reply

[deleted]

I always considered him to be the oldest brother. But I think the confusion started partly because of the line "Look what your brother did to the door". Since he didn't say "Look what OUR brother did to the door", people assumed he was their father.

Horror_Metal

reply

Horror_Metal (love that name, btw, two of my favorite things in life), that is the part that gets cited the most when people try to refute my assertion that he's their brother!

People point to that line as if he would only say that if he was their father, but he seems to hold them in total disdain, so I just take that line as a way of distancing himself from Leatherface, putting himself in a position of superiority. Like, he thinks they're these bumbling idiots who require his supervision, so he says "your brother" rather then "our brother" because he wants to remain superior.

Or something like that.



reply

[deleted]

Perhaps, now this is just a thought, maybe he is both brother and father. That would accommodate all plot holes in the dialogue while simultaneously adding to the taboo tally in these movies.

reply

The cook (my favorite movie character of all time, by the way) is the brother and there is no "theory" to it. I know his is the brother because Tobe Hooper says so in the commentary. If the person who created him says so, that's good enough for me.









--------------------------------
I did sixty in five minutes once...

reply