I did PM you just now while I'm watching the amazing "Mannequins of Horror" episode of "Monsters". The stop-motion work is excellent, and it really has horrific moments.
I agree about there being good uses for CGI, as in LOTR trilogy and the Jurassic Park films. "Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow" does a wonderful job of combining a story with lots of CGI. There has to be a strong or at least an entertaining story to attach effects to. Too often, it seems they are thinking, "We can do all of this cool stuff! They'll never notice the weaknesses." Scarily, they might not see those failings themselves because they are so blown away by their own effects. Ray Harryhausen has commented that they fail to work on the story as much as the effects; they must start with a good story then decorate it with effects. I watched "Jason and the Argonauts" again a couple of days ago, and time rolled back to when I first saw it at the drive-in when I was about 12 years old. Talos creakingly turning his head still causes chills; that whole sequence is one of my top favorites of all time, even better than the battle with the skeletons and the hydra. Many CGI creations simply aren't anywhere as effective as the old-time creatures.
I actually like "old school" effects much better because they add certain artistry; they aren't trying to look exactly as in real life. "Skull Mountain" has a very atmospheric look, with the old-style storm effects (for an example). A remake could work, but I doubt that it would have the qualities of the original.
You're right: Some remakes do work. It's just that we've had such a long stream of poorly done ones in which they completely ignore what makes the original special. I've read people suggesting that they remake lesser-known movies, which could work because most people wouldn't have as much of an attachment of the original. Only, would they take this movie and twist it into some parody/comedy? Well... Actually, if it was approached correctly, that might work! They, there would be two very different versions. Unfortunately, too often, when they try parodies, they are merely cruel. Does that make sense?
~~NystMoonstruck~~
reply
share