what a great documentary


I loved the way the film maker juxtaposed the view taken by some US servicement compared to that of the Vietnamese.

It was just so raw and real, you could get a real sense of the two sides conflicting views, as well as the lengths they would go to to be victorious.

I don't think the American administration of the time could have been shown in a worse light. It exposed them as being rotten to the core, full of lies. They were basically brain washing an entire nation with 'spin'. The age old story of dehumanizing the 'enemy' and making it easier for the soldiers to kill them and deal with the consequences.

The segment with the general talking about how the Vietnamese didn`t value life as much as the Americans made me sick.

The Americans were the enemy in this war, the Vietnamese people were simply defending their homeland.

It is a similar case to what is happening today in the middle east. I can`t believe the US has learned nothing from the past 50 years.

Ironically the actions of the US to do away with communist societies and encourage capitalism will ultimately lead to the demise of the USA as a super power if it has not already.

China was a sleeping giant and has emerged from its slumber. The US has over stretched its forces in a poor attempt to police the world. The US may have to face up to its history soon enough.

reply

Great post.

reply

Definitely agree with you. It was incredibly potent the way they edited the Vietnamese crying over their dead, then William C. Westmoreland talking about them not valuing human life, then cutting to shots of the US bombing Vietnam. That was horrific, but genius in the way it was presented.

The rawness of it was great. You just don't get that in documentaries any more, as far as I've seen. They're all presented in such a slick manner, they've lost that edge...

reply

this is the most true post written on imdb

reply

Very good! interesting. didn't think I would like it. never been into war politics
but this caught my attention. the older I get the more interesting this part of History
has gotten to me. informative for sure.

reply

What I liked was the interviews with the two soldiers (The guy with big afro, and the white guy with the smaller perm.) As the movie goes along, the onion peel on those two keeps getting peeled away, when you finally realized they were severely injured during the war.

reply

Yes that was great. and Randy.

reply