I remember seeing this at the time and being really disappointed by it.
I'm a huge Porridge fan, but I think it was a big mistake to re-visit the character. You can't go back.
It wasn't even as though they'd made an effort to do an actual episode. It was just a kind of cynical documentary-style thing, which I felt was short on real laughs, and was completely without any charm or affection for the character or the programme. I just found it really sad, and I wouldn't want to see it again.
If I recall rightly, the same programme-makers also did an update of a few other comedy characters of the '70s - one of which was Margo from The Good Life. Now, don't get me wrong. TGL wasn't in the same league as Porridge. But it was OK, and Margo was an enjoyable character. The problem with the update was the same: she was older (obviously) and seemed to have lost all the charm and likeability that she had in TGL. The character was completely out of context without the others, and seemed lost in a modern setting. In her case the 'back-story,' we were casually told, was that she had divorced her husband Jerry - which just seemed gratuitous and sad. I mean, why do that? :(
That's my opinion anyway. If anyone loves Porridge and Going Straight, I recommend you just enjoy them as they were: enshrined in their perfect 1970s capsule. and try and avoid seeing this aberration.
_____________
"Maybe I should go alone"
- Quint, Jaws.
reply
share