MovieChat Forums > The Wicker Man (1974) Discussion > i always thought Howe was too religious

i always thought Howe was too religious


would have been better if he wasn't.

reply

I liked it. It made the contrast between the locals and the outsider more pronounced.

reply

i thought being a rational person should have been enough.

reply

Howie was pretty rational, at least at first. As they started to get to him, he got more unhinged and twitchy.

reply

i thought it was overkill. still a good movie.

reply

They could've toned him down without losing the contrast. I didn't mind it, but I could see where it might've gone over-the-top at points.

reply

Yep, they'll do that :)

reply

The psychological aspect of this movie is very disturbing, yes. It's clearly the element that has meant the endurance of this film as a classic over the years.

reply

It's not just does he contrast in belief, but intensity of how he practices his religion. Him being brought up where homogeneity to himself was assumed, his background in worship is comparatively weak, thus his prayers and curse can seem ineffectual as he's unpracticed.

reply

I never took him as being all that in-your-face until they started toying with him. At first, he seemed to silently disapprove but said very little except for the times when he was directly engaged. It wasn’t until they started screwing with him that he began to go off the rails but at that point, it was warranted as he had good reason to suspect the entire island was in on the “disappearance”.

reply

Wrong. The film is about the toxic aspects of religion. The final moments of Howie screaming Christian proclamations while the cult sing their cheerful song as their sacrifice burns alive is key. Notice how the wicker man collapses to reveal the sun, the first thing to be worshipped by man, as the film ends.

Howie’s religiosity is an essential part of the film’s theme, and explains why he’d be a virgin.

reply

“Notice how the wicker man collapses to reveal the sun, the first thing to be worshipped by man”

Great observation. Thank you for posting this.

reply