too much singing??


i think so.

reply

Nope. It was a key element of the Summerislanders’ pagan lifestyle. I found the music in the film wonderfully creepy.

reply

I loved the singing. It completely took me by surprise and some of the songs were good.

reply

I think not.

reply

Singing has long been a staple in worship, education, and indoctrination. Also in setting the creepy, off-putting, or unfamiliar vibe.
I disagree with you.

reply

No.

reply

I actually bought the soundtrack on CD when I first saw this movie in 2002. I used to play it in my car all the time. The singing and instrumentation was very enchanting and The Landlord's Daughter was always a good source of comic relief.

reply

Any sings written specifically for the film?

reply

I seem to recall there was a song called Maypole that had to have been written for the film. It referenced 'Summerisle,' which I believe was a fictional locale devised for the film. I seem to recall looking at the liner notes and I think most of the songs were original to the film.

reply

Brilliant soundtrack. There are several releases of which I have two: Canal and Silva Screen. Shame my favorite song, the main title “The Highland Widow’s Lament” is only available on the mono version that includes all audio from the film like Howie’s sea plane, but I’ll take what I can get.

reply

You can never have too much singing.

reply

No, I think all the singing gave the movie and edge of utter weirdness that works beautifully! It's utterly baffling to the stuffy protagonist, gives the whole thing a loopy unreality that puts the viewer off guard.

Ugly reality isn't restored until the very end, and even then, it's a super-weird reality.

reply

I really like the music and singing.

reply