It's such a shame...


...that apparently some people are unable to find the greatness of this film. Yes, it's long. But that's entirely the point. Yes, the male lead isn't your typical sympathetic protagonist. But again, he's not meant to be. Because that's not how life is. Is Leaud playing somewhat of a variation on most of his other roles? Well, yes, but he does so with such skill, you actually begin to be charmed by him. You accept his long-winded self absorption with appreciative amusement. If your attention span can hold out for more than one minute, you should be able to find something positive about this film.

reply

I have seen a lot of French movies that have the actors do nothing but talk throughout the movie. I prefer to see people talking than having a lot of violence and socalled action nonsense.

reply

This is one of the greatest film I have ever seen ! Great dialogue !

How about a DVD ?

- Who is God ?
- When you close your eyes and make a wish, God is the one who doesn't care about.

reply

dvds are coming this spring in France...

reply

That's great ! I live in France !

- Who is God ?
- When you close your eyes and make a wish, God is the one who doesn't care about.

reply

In spring ? When exactly ? Have you got a release date ?

- Who is God ?
- When you close your eyes and make a wish, God is the one who doesn't care about.

reply

Not really, the source is from an Eustache's relatives. it seems they are releasing the dvd themselves so there's no exact date so far.

reply

I completely agree with the o.p. I think this is one beautiful film, definitely in my top 5 of all time. I actually found Leaud's character very loveable, in fact. I know that he is self-absorbed but that makes him all the more charming (for me at least). I really don't understand all the criticism towards his character; of course he is the perfect representation of the narcisstic intellectual who loves to hear himself talk; nevertheless, he is very interesting to listen to and much of what he says is spot on. I saw him as a truly disillusioned person who cannot buy into the "machine" of modern society. I can perfectly relate to that. I can relate to him and also to Veronika. Alexandre is putting on an act throughout the film, but it is endearing because it is so obvious. When Veronika shatters this barrier or mask that he has raised, it is all the more shocking and even painful for him. She is able to reach him: he who had previously made efforts to keep an emotional distance. On another note, I'd be quite interested to know how closely J.P. Leaud resembles the character of Alexandre. He is really wonderful in this film, and I know that Leaud puts alot of himself into his characters; I believe he has even mentioned this in an interview.

I don't want realism. I want magic!

reply

wooow thank you
2. Midnight cowboy (Schlesinger, 69') nice

My TOP 200 Movies -http://www.imdb.com/list/iFa7p7uwsr8/

reply

that apparently some people are unable to find the greatness of this film
Yes ,they are.And I'm part of them!

I wish I could be like Gladstone Gander.

reply

the copy i saw had such atrocious translation that probably ruined alot of the dialogue's for me

shame, i might have enjoyed it more if the translation was good




so many movies, so little time

reply