MovieChat Forums > The Friends of Eddie Coyle (1973) Discussion > Could Jackie Brown have turned the table...

Could Jackie Brown have turned the tables on Coyle?


When Eddie turns in gun-runner Jackie Brown (Steven Keats), he scores some points for himself with the Fed, Dave Foley. However, Eddie has been committing a crime himself by buying guns from Brown. It seems to me that turning in Brown could have back-fired on Eddie. Brown could have fingered Coyle as a gun buyer, as part of a plea-bargain to reduce his own sentence. He also could have done this to get revenge, because it is clear when he is arrested that he realizes that it was Eddie who set him up (I’m not sure why he didn’t also suspect the hippies).
However, I can also think of a couple of reasons why Brown would NOT have fingered Coyle. For one thing, he knows Coyle works with the mob, and he’s heard Eddie’s story about the knuckle-breaking. He might fear that he would suffer mob vengeance, even in jail. Also, perhaps there could have no plea-bargaining for someone selling machine guns—as Brown said, “That’s life in this state.”
It’s interesting that when he’s arrested, Brown says (thinking of Coyle), “I’ll take care of it myself.”
The Criterion DVD includes stills of scenes deleted from the movie. There is a still of Brown and Foley at the police station. It would be interesting to know what was said in that scene.

reply

hey book!

Yeah I thought that was interesting as well. I figured that Jackie didn't tell Foley right away about Eddie because he was so enraged that he (Eddie) had set him up, that he wanted to exact revenge by himself - in his own way.

I can only imagine what the deleted scenes showed - I mean if they changed anything from the way it was in the book. You'll see some very interesting answers and clues in the book! At the police station, they discussed trying to convince Jackie that the two hippies (the would be bankrobbers who'd purchased machine guns from him etc., ) were the ones who'd turned him in (you'll read why in the book) but knew he wouldn't buy that one at all. I won't give away any more and spoil it for you. You'll love the book as much as the movie. (I found the book by the way, sitting on the shelves at my local library collecting dust - in fact the librarian said that the book had not been checked out in "ages and ages". Ha - unbelievable!

"This lifes hard man but its harder if you're stupid!" (Steven Keats as Jackie Brown)

reply

Thanks. I will probably look for the book at my library also. Haven’t tried reading a detective novel since I read some of Raymond Chandler’s stuff ages ago—but “Coyle” should be worth checking out!

reply

Yeah, not the smartest move.

I think that Coyle was banking on Jackie Brown not being able to figure it out, and also that Brown didn't actually know who Coyle was, and maybe wouldn't be able to rat him out.

Also, Coyle was pretty stressed out over his situation, that he was desperate to do something to get himself off the hook.

reply


The question is how could Brown "take care of it himself" ? He was about to be sentenced to life for selling machine guns. A bit of a flaw in an otherwise great movie. Also as the first review states as great as Mitchum is in this movie Stephen Keats (as Brown ) steals this movie. Too bad his career didn't take off after this. Same goes for Richard Jordan as Foley. I guess because the film itself wasn't a big success.

reply

I thought it was a bit of a mis-step in an otherwise well executed script that Jackie jumped immediately to Eddie as setting him up. Seems he would go straight to the hippies as the party till he knew better.

Also, seems to me that Jackie would be to savvy based upon previous scenes as to actually have the rifles on him at his very next meeting with some clearly shaky buyers.

Maybe the confidence that he shows in setting things right on his own is based upon the fact that (though we don't see it) they have nothing to actually prosecute him for as they had not yet searched the car to find it empty.

reply