MovieChat Forums > The Starlost (1973) Discussion > One simple question...?

One simple question...?


I don't understand why you would not let the inhabitants know they are on spaceship if it intended on eventually landing on a habitable planet anyway.

reply

.......they knew in the beginning. But shortly after the Ark left Earth orbit, an accident happened to the nuclear reactors and killed the crew. The Ark then drifted for so many hundreds of years in space that some (not all) people on board forgot.

reply

The Ark had a mishap and was lost for hundreds of years before the main characters find it is a space ship

reply

Some of the biospheres' inhabitants know what is going on. For example, the episode with the medical team. Others have lost their knowledge of the past due to the passage of time, or by choice. I suspect that our heroes' home biosphere, Cypress Corners, intentionally witheld this information from younger generations in order to keep them pure and untouched by the outside.

reply

I noted that also: The people in the astronomy section, the Space Medics and "Mr. Smith of Manchester" all seem to be aware that their is a greater population on the Ark but purposefully remain isolated and don't venture beyond their particular sections -- I wonder if maybe this wasn't a continuity error due to the writers not understanding Ellison's series bible and just producing random stories with no regard for his original premise. Which states that ALL of the surviving inhabitants had forgotten they were on the ship and regard tales of Earth in the same way we regard tales of Atlantis. So either these people who are aware they are on the Ark just don't care, or the writers screwed up.

I was just reading Ellison's foreward to the novelization of "Phoenix Without Ashes" and he implies that the producers were commissioning the scripts before his bible had even been finished. They really did screw everything up, it should have been an amazing show, as it turned out it's merely offbeat & fascinating, often in a bad sort of way but still fascinating.

reply

I noted that also: The people in the astronomy section, the Space Medics and "Mr. Smith of Manchester" all seem to be aware that their is a greater population on the Ark but purposefully remain isolated and don't venture beyond their particular sections -- I wonder if maybe this wasn't a continuity error due to the writers not understanding Ellison's series bible and just producing random stories with no regard for his original premise. Which states that ALL of the surviving inhabitants had forgotten they were on the ship and regard tales of Earth in the same way we regard tales of Atlantis. So either these people who are aware they are on the Ark just don't care, or the writers screwed up.

I was just reading Ellison's foreward to the novelization of "Phoenix Without Ashes" and he implies that the producers were commissioning the scripts before his bible had even been finished. They really did screw everything up, it should have been an amazing show, as it turned out it's merely offbeat & fascinating, often in a bad sort of way but still fascinating.


Some of the domes might have still remembered the true nature of the Ark, but were unable to do anything about it because they didn't have access. Remember, the keys to open the tube doors were not common possessions. Devon had them, but others - including, apparently, Mr Smith From Manchester - did not.

reply

This is a similar premise from Star Trek: TOS... For the World is Hollow And I have Touched The Sky....


...by the way, wasn’t there one episode where the culture under one biosphere lived like gangsters? ...and wasn’t that somewhat reminiscent of another Star Trek: TOS... A Piece of The Action?

Even as kid watching this when it first came out, I remember how dull and depressing this show was.


Smoke me a kipper. I’ll be back for breakfast

reply

[deleted]