MovieChat Forums > Some Mothers Do 'Ave 'Em (1973) Discussion > Frank's back, but for FOX [article]

Frank's back, but for FOX [article]


TV's Frank Spencer to make return, but for Fox in the US

By James Macintyre
Published: 18 October 2007, The Independent [UK]


He was the character that made you wince at the screen more, perhaps, than any other on British television. And he appeared to be long gone.

But, in a move that risks as many groans as it does leaps of joy among his cult of fans with fond memories of the 1970s, the effeminate, haphazard disaster-zone that is Frank Spencer is set to make a return, in spirit at least, to the small screen.

The BBC has been asked to get working on scripts for a pilot episode of an American remake of the classic comedy Some Mothers Do 'Ave 'Em, at the request of Fox TV, the American network owned by Rupert Murdoch. In what may prove one of the media mogul's more eccentric risks, Fox has asked the Beeb's Worldwide Production arm and Sony Pictures to embark on the revival, according to the Hollywood magazine Variety.

The extraordinary and somewhat unlikely news was greeted with glee by Raymond Allen, the creator of the original, which ran from 1973 to 1978 on BBC1 and embedded the brilliant, painfully awkward performances of Michael Crawford to the nation's psyches, if not hearts.

"I never would have dreamt 35 years ago when I originally wrote the series that dearly loved but disastrous Frank would be creating havoc on American soil," said Mr Allen, barely able to contain his jubilation. "It's a very exciting time... and a treasured moment of glory for Frank!"

In Some Mothers, the hapless but constantly optimistic Spencer – known to millions still for his catchphrase "Ooh Betty" – was constantly struggling to please his long-suffering, attractive red-head wife played by Michele Dotrice. Often dressed in his trade-mark beret and grey trench-coat, Spencer would plough into people's lives during his attempts, frequently causing calamitous accidents and even nervous breakdowns.

The first episode saw Spencer encouraged by the sensible and apparently normal Betty to go for a job interview as a sales rep to an ironmonger, or – as Spencer could not stop calling it – "wholeiron salemonger".

On arrival, Spencer causes an office assistant to topple from the top of a ladder simply by his unhinged grin; gets stuck in the lift for hours and – during the interview itself – proceedes to make a number of breakages, a tendency which caused Betty's original desire to get him out the house.

Some Mother's is the latest in a line of British comedy's to be remade for American screens, ranging from the 1970s sitcom Steptoe and Son, which became Stanford and Son, to, more recently, The Office for NBC.

The executive producer of BBC Worldwide, Paul Telegdy said: "We have felt for a while now that Some Mothers Do 'Ave 'Em would translate brilliantly across the pond."

reply

It'll be a disaster, just like Frank!

American tv adaptations suck, just look at their versions of The Office, Fawlty Towers, Ab Fab etc. The humour is different, it just doesn't translate very well.

reply

Agreed.

Though I was lucky enough to come across the original series a couple of years ago, and quite enjoyed them.

"Oooh, Betty!"

reply

won't even last a season, only in america would they dream to carve up one of the funniest comedies ever made all for making a new dollar since there out of ideas dear me shame.

reply

the usa allways mess our comedy up, they have'nt got a clue!

We're gonna find out who's the Thing!

R J MacReady

reply

i must admit i am not terribly optmistic... but this is a great idea, even if in reality it turns out to be not such a good one... it would be great it it was as good as the original (which i saw the entire series of twice first whilst staying at my grandparents on video in 2000 and recently on tv repeats) but of course one mustn't expect such... a perfect example of bringing back a great series and ruining it in the process is the revival of Doctor Who (the surviving eps i saw from 03 to 06 on repeats). But using modern equipment and special effects wasn't its downfall. Using modern acting and manners was. Whilst i wouldn't argue against using mobiles in the series perhaps the new digital age should have, rather than keeping the doctor confined to england, allowed for star wars esque backdrops using greenscreen so as to expand his earthly and unearthly range.... And similarly whilst SMDAE could well come back as good or better than the first series, i have (whilst not fear) apprehension as regards its quality. The yanks may have the cash... but they seem dimwitted people who might not be able to reproduce or appreciate the type of humour used in SMDAE. Therefore the best case scenario is it is made in the style f the original, with just the right cast script jokes etc... as to rather than change the show to meet a new audience, change the show to change the audience.

reply