I love the musical "Man of La Mancha" and recently wrapped up a production of it in which I played The Barber. And since this time I have been thinjknig of a good remake cast since I feel the first effort wasn't all it could be.
Cervantes/Don Quixote: Antonio Banderas Aldonza: An Unknown Sancho: Jack Black Governor/Innkeeper: Jonathan Pryce The Padre: Mandy Patinkin The Housekeeper: Patti Lupone Antonia: An unknown The Duke/ Dr. Sanson Carrasco: Robert Sean Leonard The Barber: Jason Alexander
I hope these ideas are pretty good but if any of you can think of any more suggestions please don't hesitate to share.
Cervantes/Don Quixote---Christopher Lloyd Sancho------------------Jason Alexander Aldonza-----------------Catherine Zeta-Jones The Governor/The Innkeeper-Michael Gambon The Duke/Dr. Carrasco---Johnny Depp Antonia-----------------Brittany Spears The Housekeeper---------Beatrice Arthur The Padre---------------Dom DeLuise The Barber--------------Gilbert Gottfried Pedro-------------------Danny Trejo Maria------------------Patti Lupone Captain of the Inquisition-Alan Rickman
I've done the show 4 times-most recently last May-and always as The Governor/The Innkeeper.(I'm a Bass.)I just think that Pryce is too refined for the role.
Cervantes/Don Quixote--Brian Stokes Mitchell Sancho----------------Jason Alexander Aldonza----------------Catherine Zeta Jones(listen to her in "Chicago") The Governor/The Innkeeper-Michael Gambon the Duke/Dr. Carrasco--David Hyde Pearce Antonia---------------Scarlett Johanson The Housekeeper-------Beatrice Arthur The Padre--------------William Christopher The Barber------------Gilbert Gottfried Maria -----------------Olympia Dukakis Pedro-----------------Danny Trejo Anselmo---------------Antonio Banduras Captain---------------Alan Rickman
Kevin Kline would be a better Cervantes/Quixote than Antonio Banderas.
I know Banderas is Hispanic, but he is just too good looking. He would be better cast as the muleteer who sings "Little Bird, Little Bird".
Either Selma Hayek or Penelope Cruz would make a good Aldonza - if either of them can sing.
Britney Spears would be an atrocious choice in any Broadway musical.
The Padre is a serious tenor role. Dom DeLuise would be totally wrong. I can't picture him as a sympathetic idealist, let alone a man of the church, at all- at least not a serious one.
Johnny Depp may be good in other films, but he would never be a convincing Dr. Carrasco. Dr. Carrasco is a stuffy, self-centered jerk, and I can't picture Depp at all in the role.
Christopher Lloyd may be a passable Quixote, but he would be a disaster as Cervantes. He is just too eccentric.
You sir, if you are not already working for a movie production house (perhaps specializing in remakes of already good movies for quick cash), should avoid seeking a career in the movie production business. Seeing as it is already full of talentless, money worshipping, lazy, soul destroying, shameless hacks. Your particular ideas, while still offending the public at large who like old movies the way they are and don't want their memory tarnished by shoddy remakes, would also be looked down upon by the other no good talentless hacks out there.
If on the other hand you do already work for one of those production houses and are perhaps vetting your ideas with the public before recommending your production house buy up the rights to this film, then I dutifully suggest that you seek redemption by removing yourself from polite society by placing yourself in solitary confinement on a deserted island. Take some of your producer friends with you. Please, do everyone a favor.
For everyone else reading this poor, pathetic thread, do any of you notice that whenever you visit the page for a really good movie from a few decades ago, there is sure to be someone there asking everyone what they would think of a remake of this and who would you like to see cast in it and here is what I would change about it? Is IMDB being used by producers to vet ideas about easy to make remakes? Are we in fact helping them to put out substandard product based on well made movies, whose only crime was to have been made before the 14 to 25 year old crowd had a chance to see them? Will using the same script and adding todays special effects make up for the substandard acting that inevitably infests these remakes? I say that if these parasites who have taken over Hollywood cannot come up with ideas of their own then they should step down and hand the reigns of power in Hollywood to a new generation of film makers who are willing to take a chance instead of retreading older movies into mediocrity.
Anyone else who agrees deserves a swift, solid kick in the posterior. Enough with remakes, and cease the idiocy of making a remake thread for every classic film.
Remakes: for the greedy and ignorant. I am neither.
Nicely put. Although I wonder if a "new generation of film makers who are willing to take a chance instead of retreading older movies into mediocrity" truly exists.
jaustin035, on Sun Dec 16 2007 18:50:29, wrote something that made me laugh.
What I said to another person, I'm also going to say to you: ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- What about all of those stage productions of Man Of La Mancha? Aren't they 'remakes' of a sort?
Get this through your snobby head; most people on this board and off it don't like this version of Man Of La Mancha-that's why there are discussions about possible remakes. Also, I find it hard to believe that Hollywood producers go on IMDB looking for movie remake ideas in the message board when they most likely have full workdays; even if they did, so what?
If you don't like this discussion, stop being a troll and don't click on it when the subject title appears on your computer screen. Very simple!
I have an alternative. Why not only add remake threads for bad films. There's no reason to remake a good film, it was already great, but remake a bad film, and make a better one instead.
My choice for Don Quixote/Cervantes would have been Richard Harris. Now that he's no longer with us, I just dunno.
For Aldonza/Dulinea . . . well, you'll laugh, but I honestly think Madonna would be my choice.
Or if you can't accept that, then by all means Liza Minelli.
The main thing I want in a remake is: Please don't go back and forth from the prison to the realistic setting. Set the whole thing in the prison, as the play was writ in the first place.
I am also against one remake after another, and I too am getting sick of this kind of thread. Please, no remakes of "Casablanca", "The Wizard of Oz", or any other great films, except maybe Shakespeare plays - and those had better be good, not crap like Baz Luhrmann's "Romeo + Juliet" or the Ethan Hawke "Hamlet".
A film does not have to be remade simply because a new generation exists. The new generation has to be taught to appreciate the older classics. I have just heard that they are remaking "Fame" with a new cast. WHY?!?!? The original was made in 1980! It's not as if it were technologically primitive.
The thought of a remake of this classic makes my skin crawl.
What about all of those stage productions of Man Of La Mancha? Aren't they 'remakes' of a sort?
Get this through your snobby head; most people on this board and off it don't like this version of Man Of La Mancha-that's why there are discussions about possible remakes. Also, I find it hard to believe that Hollywood producers go on IMDB looking for movie remake ideas in the message board when they most likely have full workdays; even if they did, so what?
If you don't like this discussion, stop being a troll and don't click on it when the subject title appears on your computer screen. Very simple!
reply share
I approve of this suggestion. I became a fan of "Man of La Mancha" after having seen the episode "To catch a falling star" on Quantum Leap. Scott Bakula did a great performance as Don Quixote in that episode.
I'll bite Cervantes/Don Quixote: Russell Crowe Aldonza/Dulcinea: Cameron Diaz, Christina Aguilara or Traci Lords Sancho: Jason Alexander The Barber: Jack Black
Don Quitotte Robert Sean Lenonard Aldonza/Dulcinea Amy Adams {if she could play the sweet Naive princess in enchanted which involved alot of singing why couldn't she do it here} the barber Jack Black Maria Melissa Newman Padre Dev Patal the innkeeper Darren Le Gallo [not as big a star as fiance/baby mama mentioned above is}
"why are you married to him then if you can't work with him how do you live with him?"