MovieChat Forums > The Godfather (1972) Discussion > What do you think this is the Army, whe...

What do you think this is the Army, where you shoot'em a mile away?


I love how Michael barely reacts to this line from Sonny. And how ignorant it shows his brother to be.

I wonder if Coppola had his druthers when making this movie he might have included a flashback to Michael's service with the Marines at Guadalcanal and Peleliu. The fighting Michael experienced there was some of the worst in the entire war. It was just about everything BUT shooting the enemy from a mile away. It was up close and personal. Often hand to hand. Way, way worse than just about any of the mob hits that are depicted in these movies.

The irony is that much of the combat Michael saw was pretty much the way Sonny described it. With the enemy's brains splattered all over his dungarees.

reply

I never thought about this before, but you are correct about Sonny's ignorance and what Michael experienced.

reply

I love this part - it shows Sonny is a reactionary, naive hothead while Michael is cold and calculating. Sonny isn't taking him seriously and runs the business with his emotions while Michael is as serious and scheming as his father. Just a great juxtaposition between brothers.

reply

The only time there would have been hand to hand combat for him would be at the Battle of Guadalcanal, but even that was no guarantee, especially if he was in the rear. The majority of US army and marines in the Pacific never even saw a Japanese soldier.

reply

The majority of soldiers and marine in any theater of the war never saw an enemy soldier.

reply

I haven’t done my research on WWII but in Nam from what I understand the biggest challenge the soldiers faced was boredom. They would go months without seeing a single enemy combatant but would have a couple of moments of shear terror

reply