Three Greatest Westerns


I rate this as one of the three very greatest westerns.

Shane, High Noon, and Culpepper Cattle Company.

reply

Apparently, you haven't seen many Westerns.

reply

Is there something wrong with SHANE, HIGH NOON or this film, in your eyes?

reply

While both pretty good movies, I wouldn't rank them as Great

Red River, and The Searchers are better


You don't have to stand tall, but you do have to stand up!

reply

Not for nothin', but you must be ridiculously hard to please if you don't regard HIGH NOON or SHANE as being "great" movies.

That said, I agree that THE SEARCHERS and RED RIVER are remarkable films, although I'm not convinced that they're better than SHANE or HIGH NOON. On par with them, sure, but better? Nah. Just my take.

reply

[deleted]