MovieChat Forums > The Carey Treatment (1972) Discussion > Am I the only one who found this movie f...

Am I the only one who found this movie funny...


...in a so-bad-it's-good way? Most of the other reviews are middling to positive, with no mention of the comically over-saturated melodrama, and the one bad review doesn't mention finding humor in the audacious caricature of a movie? Maybe it's just me and over-the-top melodrama - I laughed at Kenneth Branagh's Dr. Frankenstein too, and indeed received some dirty looks for it.

SPOILERS

But come on - by the time Coburn got to interrogating that teenage friend of the deceased, he was practically going Guantanamo on her with that station wagon insanity ride. And then the massive red-herring at the end, after all of that build up... astonishing.

I guess if you were really trying to stick with the drama they were trying to maintain, it would become more annoying than comical.

Of course, this is not one you hear about much. I was surprised that more than 5 people had ever seen it.

reply

Could you please tell me where you got it, or sell me a copy? My email is [email protected]. I've looked every where for it! Thanks.

reply

Greetings,
Did you ever find a source for this? I am still looking.
Regards,
wfw
<[email protected]>

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

it was just boring



I Worship The Goddess Amber Tamblyn


reply

Leonard Maltin's guide gives it a three out of four. I guess you are the only one who laughed at it.

reply

I'm watching it right now on Turner Classic Movie channel. I can not stop laughing. It truly is so bad it's good. The confrontation in the kitchen with the uncle who is whipping up some gourment sauce had me in stitches. Especially when Coburn snaps: "Would'ya cut the Julia Child bit already!?"

And the oh-too-pretty masuesse giving Coburn a massage is so insanely homoerotic hillarious espcially when pretty boy mentions balling his chick, as if!

I can totally appreciate the direction. It's great but the overall movie is stinker. Even Coburn stinks.

reply

Did anyone else think of Raymond in seinfeild??šŸ¤£

reply

eh ā€¦ It ainā€™t so bad.

Then again, it ainā€™t so good either.

Sort of like watching an extended episode of the Mod Squad.

Seemed to be all about watching Coburn swagger from one setting to another. Sometimes engaging in unnecessarily extreme behaviors.

The worst parts were at the end ā€”

1- I mean, the police confront a hazy guy with a knife. Was it really necessary to shoot him?

2 - ā€˜Free Loveā€™ sensibilities aside, we have to accept that his sideways offer of marriage at the close of the story was the standard of the day when the movie was made.


Oh joy ā€¦ ā€˜In Like Flintā€™ is coming on next. That should make everything better,



ā€œYour thinking is untidy, like most so-called thinking today.ā€ (Murder, My Sweet)

reply

Definitely fabulously cheesy.

I loved the scenes mentioned, also the scene with the prep school roommate.

Why would a hip single guy who is always on the make drive an ocean liner of a station wagon? Apparently, it's because he realizes that you can go one hell of a high speed rampage in one. They are impossible to damage and handle wonderfully on any terrain. Who knew?

Who knew that a doctor could identify birth control pills like he was sampling coke? Just taste one and then spit it out.

And the girl was mildly freaking out when he was driving like a maniac, but then he stops and demands that she help his investigation. She keeps freaking out all of the way back to campus.



reply

I haven't seen it in a long longggggg time but I remember liking Coburn over-the-top or not.

Kisskiss, Bangbang

reply

I just watched this thing, and it is AWFUL. Hilariously MST3K bad. BLAKE f-ing EDWARDS directed this garbage??????

reply

I didn't find it boring, just really really really unrealistic. Like he's a doctor at a hospital, and he rarely shows up for work, and when they are counseling him on this matter it's treated like a minor detail of his job...like his scrubs are the wrong shade of green or something. And one person after another lets him into his/her house, dorm, jail, work place, etc. without ever asking him to confirm he is who he says he is. And he's in a phone booth that gets hit square by a speeding car and he's up walking around a couple hours later after just 12 stitches. He also recklessly drives that poor girl across what seems to be about half of New England without ever seeing a cop.

But the best thing about it is his car, as noted by someone else above. I mean he's this ultra-cool cat from the west coast and he tools around town in a gigantic station wagon with fake wood paneling and a luggage rack on top. Every movie in the past 50 years which has had an ultra-cool, sharply dressed hero makes sure we know he's cool because he's got a cool car (McQueen's Mustang in "Bullitt" for example). But in this one Coburn's wheels actually foreshadow Clark Griswald's land yacht in Nat. Lampoon's Vacation.

reply

So, in other words, it's BAD......

reply

TY! I too thought immediately of Vacation when I saw that ridiculous car in the opening scene! This entire movie was so absurd I could not figure out what the hell was going on......................until I saw the trivia that Michael Crichton was the real author! Did Crichton write this movie in one drunken night? Even James Coburn's predilection for sexist roles insulting to women had to sink to new lows to do this--no wit, no humor, and crazy crazy crazy stupid caricatures.

Blake Edwards is one of my favorite writers and directors--even when he does movies like Switch and SOB (my favorites) about guys being guys, they have me on the floor (or through it) laughing so hard....I suspend my sensibilities and pretend I'm one of the guys and laugh along as they turn into a woman, send their friend out in style, or chase bimbos in hot pants around Malibu. But that was impossible to do here. The trivia said he tried to get out of this--thank God we know he knew it was a turkey.

Crichton can be credited with some exciting fare like Jurassic Park, but his grasp on reality was often/usually tenuous where women were concerned. His attitudes toward women often were a cross between archaic and swpiteful, as we saw in the female sexual harasser in Disclosure, where beautiful and sexy Demi Moore needs to force Michael Douglas (two improbable roles outside Hollywood imo) to do her bidding sexually. Reversing the roles may have had some proximity to reality, but not in Crichton's world. Laura Dern's character in Jurassic Park was a wanna-be mother throughout the movie--with the dinosaurs, the children....she did everything but give firth and breastfeed. Unless I missed that. When Crichton verbalized his political views closer to the end of his life, they were improbably wingnut for a doctor who lived in Santa Monica, excuse me for stereotyping, but I lived for a decade at the same time as he did, and never met anyone like him......

The only female doctor in the movie is sitting in a lab where no M.D. would waste their years of education, internship, residency, etc. They do lab tests for the hospital--a job that does not require any degree at all (esp in 1972. I've known 2 who do that). She's distinctly unattractive (unlike the female doctors I met back in the 70s and 80s, for whatever reason). And even tho she's a friend of the main character's beautiful girlfriend, this doctor propositions the main character. Lovely. The only professional woman was just trying to get laid above her level. So she was delusional. The rest of the women's roles are incredibly stereotyped--bimbos, bitchy mother, women consumed by jealousy, women who do anything for a loser guy they don't really even know. None have decent relationships with anyone. Even the main love interest is ready to take back the cheating husband who walked out on her and her son. Give me a break. "He said he's changed." Blech.

The cruel abuse inherent in driving that young women around in that station wagon--as psychotic men do to women in anger, terrorizing her, giving her whiplash and other soft tissue injuries of which a doctor would be well-aware, and risking her life and safety (not even a seat belt!) is typical macho egocentrism to which Crichton subscribed. The macho doctor main character who is a PIG, never puts down his cigarette00even in 1972, I don 't remember doctors smoking inside hospitals--I remember a doctor's lounge being smokey once and we were shocked. Ir was the anesthesiologist someone said....as tho that explained it. Last, lying to police saying you are a lawyer is a crime--that cop hated him and had every right to lock him up right there. No doctors think lawyers are equal to them. Lawyers just scare them to death because lawyers can cost them so much $$ for increased malpractice premiums as a result of nuisance (and real, valid) lawsuits.

There were lots more things to horrify the Catholic Legency of Decency than the casual treatment of abortion...the concept that a doctor would provide safe abortions not for profit but to protect women's lives was actually very positive, as was demonstrating a teenager procuring an unsafe abortion in the mistaken belief she is pregnant when it's really a tumor causing her symptoms--something highly unlikely in a hospital setting with adequate testing--pregnancy tests performed throughout the scheduling and performing to verify her condition. (Both these ideas strike at the heart of anti-abortion activities of the Church.) The role played by an Asian man was breakthrough too if you ignore the gratuitous comments about his race and religion. But the rest of the macho silliness was not the macho silliness to the Church subscribed--finding and tasting birth control pills, deciding to get an abortion at any cost even at 4 months (2d trimester), sleeping with a woman still married, then taking her from her repentent husband, propositioning women for casual sex, prpositioning men for casual sex, having casual sex...everywhere, everyone... Did they run screaming from the showing of this movie?

reply

Nope. I started chuckling right at the beginning at the scene with the security guard in the parking lot, designed to show how cool Dr. Cary is in that he challenges authority figures. Now that we see how cool he is, we can now move on to propagandize our young audience on the evils of abortion on demand.

reply