anyone else see some kind of connection between the emcee in cabaret and puck from a midsummers night dream? they're both mischievous, and have to have a more profound sense of whats going on in the "humans" lives then the humans themselves. also, the grotesque, outer worldly makeup and voice help with the "not quite human" vibe i get from him.
No, I don't think it's just in your head. (I always thought it was just in mine!)
But I certainly relate to what you are suggesting. I always thought he had the qualities of one of those mischievous nature spirit types, so Puck is a very good suggestion. The way his image keeps showing up, smirking and knowing, in seemingly unrelated sequences, like during "Tomorrow Belongs to Me". I think he's very much in the tone of the animism that underlay the mythology the Nazis embraced, and I thought from the first time I saw the movie that was something Fosse was deliberately reaching for.
You might very well think that. I couldn't possibly comment.