MovieChat Forums > Are You Being Served? (1972) Discussion > Blackface / Minstrelsy in Christmas Spec...

Blackface / Minstrelsy in Christmas Specials


I love this show and watch it with my mom sometimes for a laugh - but what is up with racist blackface in 1980? Surely by then it was well known to be highly offensive and racist, and even in the US (by 1980) you wouldn't see anything like that. It's especially bad that they have it on two Christmas specials, where you think it would be more "family friendly" for the holiday. I'm glad at least for the new remake they had a "normal" black character finally to atone for this really outdated behavior.

reply

the Black and white Minstrel Show was a very popular TV show here in the 60s and 70s - it only came to an end in 1978. so i don't suppose anyone watching Are You Being served at that time would have thought of blacking up as racist. they had been used to seeing it every saturday nighr on the BBC until quite recently.

I hope the black actor in the recent revival was not cast to 'atone' for anything, but simply because they thought he was the best actor for the job. That should be the only reason for casting anyone, black or white or any other colour.

reply

Blackface didn't carry the same charge in the UK that it has in America. In Britain, especially in the era of AYBS and before, the average Englishman would have seen it as no big thing. As usual, Americans have to become completely unhinged and hysterical over anything to do with race, even an innocuous comic routine like this--where you'd have to be turning over rocks to claim it was being intended as intentionally 'racist' towards anyone.

And, also as usual, Americans love to export their neuroses around the world and force their guilt trips on everyone else. Considering the situation existing in the USA today, I don't think any American has much call getting huffy over a skit on a British television show from forty years ago. Collectively, America doesn't look to have evolved too awfully much in its attitudes towards the black man itself.

50 Is The New Cutoff Age.

reply

[deleted]

I noticed that Wendy was the only one that didn't appear in blackface. I had never remember watching either blackface episode in the States. The only time I remember seeing it here in the States was once on All in the Family and once on that Nell Carter as a maid show I can't remember the name to at the moment. I do remember thinking when I saw these episodes on the DVD set that they couldn't make it here in the States. I think it is one thing to just put on the makeup and another to actually do the Song and Dance with it. I also feel that this particular episode was one big negative stereotype to anyone from the countryside.

George
"All that is gold dose not glitter, not all those who wander are lost."

reply

Oh of course it's embarassingly racist and out of date, and not just an American "overreaction." I suppose you defend Polliwog dolla too.....

reply

There is no difference between blacking up and putting on a false beard.
Golliwog not polliwog.

reply

Anyone else exhausted by constantly looking at things from the past to get offended by?

reply