Criterion To The Rescue!


If ever a film deserved to be treated to the full Criterion Collection treatment it's the brilliant, inventive and completely endearing "They Might Be Giants." There have been so many versions of this little beauty (original theatrical release, early Anchor Bay DVD edition, two incarnations via Netflix) that it's really time to put everything together in one place and give this poignant cult classic the deluxe makeover it so desperately needs. Get Joanne Woodward to record an insightful audio commentary, re-insert the much discussed and sometimes deleted grocery store sequence, put all of the trimmed bits back and deliver this (at long last) to the faithful masses that are out there waiting to receive this with open arms.

PS - Does anybody else notice thematic similarities between this and the other James Goldman cult favorite "Evening Primrose"? All of the lovable misfits (including Rue McClanahan, F. Murray Abraham and Sudie Bond) banding together reminded me of that earlier Goldman/Stephen Sondheim production.

reply

Criterion is well known for these little known but intelligent gems, it is baffling to me why it has not happened yet. Perhaps we need to write them

reply

You may have a good point there, crmfghtr. The last I knew the public relations point of contact for the Criterion Collection was Brian Carmody -- though I haven't reached out to them in quite awhile. If any title is deserving of their attention it is certainly "They Might Be Giants."

reply

And still we wait. Fyi the netflix expiration on this movie is December 1st, hopefully something comes soon!

reply

There is a Universal Vault Series DVD of this film that is now available on Amazon for about $20. It's manufactured on demand using a DVD-R, but it's better than paying hundreds of dollars for the previous DVD. For now I'd say this is your best bet for owning this film.

http://www.amazon.com/They-Might-Giants-George-Scott/dp/B00PX7SVRY/ref =tmm_dvd_title_0?_encoding=UTF8&sr=&qid=

reply

Just discovered this film before they yanked it from Netflix. I'm worried about buying this "Vault Collection" release on Amazon because of the various cuts I've read about. Wiki entry said it was a theatrical runtime of 98min (not sure what I watched Nov.30 but it did have the grocery scene) but the Vault Coll. says 87min. Can anyone verify the runtime on either the Vault or older Anchor Bay release for me? From another vendor, it appears they would cost me about the same. I certainly wish there was a Criterion release.

reply

DigiTSKT:

I have just acquired the DVD of this film. It contains the film, a sparse commentary by the director Anthony Harvey and film archivist Robert A. Harris, an 8-minute featurette of little moment, the theatrical trailer, and some biographies. According to the DVD Savant review on the DVD Talk site, this edition was released by Anchor Bay in 2000. Oddly enough, the name "Anchor Bay" appears nowhere on the DVD case, or on the DVD label. In fact, NO manufacturer's name at all appears on the DVD or case! The picture on the cover, however, indicates that I have the same edition as the one reviewed by DVD Savant. I assume that DVD Savant's information is accurate and that this DVD was indeed released by Anchor Bay.

The DVD case says that the length of the film is 98 minutes, but in fact, on the DVD itself, the film is only 91 minutes long. (I expect that the Universal Vault edition of 87 minutes is simply the British version of 87 minutes put back into American formatting, with the 87 minutes representing a speeded-up PAL version of the original American 91 minutes. In other words, I expect that the Vault edition contains exactly what I have on my DVD, as far as the film goes, but likely the Vault version does not have the special features.)

The supermarket scene, which was supposedly entirely cut in the original theatrical release, is at least partly restored in this version. One commenter on the DVD Talk site argues that parts of this scene have been cut from this edition, but the director, in the commentary, does not confirm that. He says only that the *entire* supermarket was cut in the theatrical release and that it has now been restored -- though he seems to think the music in that scene has been tampered with. So is anything missing from the supermarket scene? I can't tell: the supermarket scene looks complete to me, but that's just my impression.

The director mentions one other short scene, of maybe a minute or so, that is missing from this edition, i.e., the scene leading up to George C. Scott's being unconscious in the library. But that would bring the total up to only 92 minutes, so if the film was originally 98 minutes -- as the IMDb claims, and as the back of the DVD case seems to indicate -- 6 more minutes are missing from somewhere. It is not obvious where they were taken from. Some of them might have been from the supermarket scene, some from elsewhere. Until some film historian puts together a definitive DVD edition, I suppose we will not know.

I, too, wish Criterion or someone would put out a definitive edition. I have written to Criterion and one or two other DVD companies requesting this, but I have no idea how seriously these DVD companies take customer suggestions.

In the meantime, this 2000 DVD (which I presume has the same runtime as the VHS which came out at about that time, though I don't know) is a good print, and the 91-minute version, if not complete, is complete enough to be a satisfying piece of film entertainment. It is certainly hard to find at an affordable price; I got lucky. But if you check the internet a few times a week, probably you will eventually find one out there for $50 or less. In the meantime, if ALL you want is the movie, and don't care about the special features, the Vault edition *might* have the same contents (slightly speeded up) as the Anchor Bay, and would be more affordable.

reply

OldFilmLover:

Just now saw your reply as I went to update on my previous post. I was able to procure a copy of the Anchor Bay "Special Edition" for under $20 via blowoutflix .com. The "grocery garden" scene I thought was present on Netflix was extended beyond what I saw prior, but as you stated, there may well be additional footage besides the single scene mentioned in the commentary, which is likely "just sitting in a vault somewhere". (Universal are lazy bums, aren't they?) Not that it necessarily makes any more sense to me to see the Netflix cut go straight from the grocer's butcher shop to the final scene, or the restored grocery garden melee bridge the gap (I believe the director said the muzak playing on the restored 2000 Anchor Bay release is indeed the original), but that's part of the charm of deconstructing this film.

For one crazy moment, I actually thought perhaps Joanne Woodward might've had a supporting role in another Don Quixote-esque gem, "Lars and the Real Girl" (2007), but filmographies refuted my speculative inquiry. Still, if one were to pair the two films for an introspective double feature, that would certainly be intriguing.

reply