MovieChat Forums > Silent Running (1972) Discussion > Why did Huey.. {SPOILER}

Why did Huey.. {SPOILER}


Have to go down with the ship? I know Lowell said that he Huey wasn't working well enough to help Dewey, but I thought Dewey could at least use the company.

I mean, it didn't seem like Huey was in any pain, using up too many resources or depressed from a loss of purpose; he was just a little gimpy.

reply

I agree, it seemed mean to take his companion away. I came to the board to post the same question.

"...as long as people can change, the world can change"

reply

See the play or the film 'Crimes Of The Heart': Lowell just didn't want to die alone.

reply

Seems the character was selfish considering how much Dewey cared.

she loved poetry and romance, but she hit the glass ceiling at birth

reply

Uh... it's a robot. I know it's easy to athropomorphize the little computerized boxes, but in the end, they were just robots, programmed to do what they did.

I'll admit, when i saw this as a child i cried at the end. Bawled like a little baby, I did. But seriously, I was a child without any real working understanding about robots or computers. It seems silly now.

"De gustibus non disputandum est"
#3

reply

Lowell was a selfish prick. Sending Dewey off all alone like that, pissed me off when I was kid and pisses me off even more now.

reply

gabby_bm writes: "...but in the end, they were just robots, programmed to do what they did."

And Freeman programmed them to feel.

Remember when they found Louie's foot? -- they felt the loss of their comrade.


 "Maybe it's another dimension. Or, you know, just really deep." --Needy

reply

Well, maybe Lowell thought that Huey was so damaged that he would eventually break down and come to a complete halt, diverting the other little guy (if they were programmed to feel, the other little guy could be diverted from his tasks by grief) from his job taking care of the plants.

I could be a morning person if morning happened at noon.

reply

The other robot showed compassion for the other robot, when it didn't want to leave it's side, while Lowell was attempting to fix it.

Lowell showed understanding of this, and let it stay there.

Lowell did not see them as just robots, and therefore it doesn't make sense that Lowell would separate them, when it was not needed for anything else.

reply