MovieChat Forums > A New Leaf (1971) Discussion > Loved the movie but personally had a sli...

Loved the movie but personally had a slight problem..


I don't know if any of you other guys observed Elaine May in this film but I found her kind of 'hot' even with the big glasses. Very quiet, educated woman with a petite figure in a dress? Why would you ever want to get rid of her after marrying her? Maybe I go to Walmart too much for a present day comparison lol. Funny how 4 decades changes our culture & belief in what's beautiful? I loved the movie too on TCM tonight. I'd never seen it but I'm a huge Walter Matthau (Charley Verrick/Taking of Pelham 123 etc.) I also really like the original 'Heartbreak Kid' with Charles Grodin (directed by May). And again, I found Elaine May very attractive in this movie. Favorite movie line among many: Matthau: DON'T LET THEM OUT!! (when the woman removes her bikini top...) I almost spit out my drink!

You're damned if you do and damned if you don't ~ Bart Simpson

reply

walmart too much! yeah, good points, and really agree about the 'heartbreak kid' with the grodin .



A day without sunshine is like, you know, night.

reply

I just caught part of this movie but came here to make the same comment....despite a bad haircut I thought the character was very pretty, especially when you compared HER looks to her co stars, the very ugly Walter Mattheau, Jack Weston and some other guy in the room. They would need LOTS of money to attract any woman...woof!

reply

c'mon matthau has got style to burn!



A day without sunshine is like, you know, night.

reply

In the scene where she is looking in the mirror before going to bed, you can see how lovely her face is. I think he was so set on seeing her as a meal ticket he was ignoring her looks. Plus, those GLASSES!

reply

I agree, Matthau was always cool looking. I really like him in his serious roles as I mentioned & who doesn't love him as a complete drunk in Bad News Bears. I have 3 teens that love/worship that movie!

You're damned if you do and damned if you don't ~ Bart Simpson

reply

It made no difference how pretty she was; Henry had no interest in women and just wanted to continue his bachelor life, which apparently did not include dating. He was entirely self-sufficient, and needed no one except Harold and his associates at his various clubs.

reply

I always assumed that Harry was gay. he seemed *very* disinterested in women, and people seemed kind of surprised that he was getting married. He just wasn't sexualy interested in his new wife.

Darling, I am trouble of the most spectacular kind!

reply

Elaine May is very hot in this film. I like her, a lot...

reply

I agree that Elaine looked good and her character had two other desirable traits - she was soft-spoken (unlike that other one with the boobs lol) and obviously intelligent. But Walter's character never complained about her looks - it was her awkward behavior patterns he disliked (at first) and later warmed up to.

reply

I don't think Walter Matthau was gay in this film; I think he was more asexual. He just didn't care one way or the other for men or women. He was a total narcissist who loved himself.

If he had sex at all, it was probably masturbation, because, as Woody Allen once noted, masturbation is sex with the person you adore the most.

reply

I don't think Walter Matthau was gay in this film; I think he was more asexual. He just didn't care one way or the other for men or women. He was a total narcissist who loved himself.

Makes sense to me. I would've loved to see something about him indicating that he was one or the other. His problem when Renee Taylor's character wasn't that she was throwing herself at him, but that he was being attacked by mosquitoes.

reply

[deleted]

Didn't you notice him swatting mosquitoes left and right before she took off her bikini?

reply

This film reminds me of Arthur (1981); in that both the Dudley Moore and the Walter Matthau characters are told that they would be economically benefited by marriage. And both characters feel forced and unwilling to do so.

Even though the Elaine May character is a pretty and educated woman, Matthau's character doesn't see a need for her (nor any other woman) after marriage. Henry Graham has never been emotionally and intimately involved with a woman, nor cared for one. Thus he has no respect, understanding, or a sense of responsibility towards women. All he plans to do is to marry Henrietta and dump her after acquiring her inheritance, and after paying back a loan to his uncle. He doesn't see a long-term commitment with Henrietta and his courtship and marriage have been obligatory and false. He doesn't want to constantly attend to and take care of a woman and feel an overwhelming sense of responsibility; nor does he want a woman that will dominate his everyday life and disrupt his routines.


...sometimes nothin' can be a real cool hand. ~ Cool Hand Luke

reply

Notice that after their meeting and quiet moment together, Henrietta became progressively more beautiful; while Henry started to be less acerbic and stopped talking about carbon on the valves.

reply