Concentration Camp?


I just saw the movie for the first time, and I MUST have this question answered: Harold views Maude's forearm near the end of the movie; it appeared that Maude had numbers tattooed there. Was Maude a concentration camp survivor? This would explain her zest to live every day as if it were her last.

reply

Was Maude a concentration camp survivor?


That is what I take from the film.

reply

Thanks for responding, sdckapr.

reply

Yes. And it was great that the point was so understated.

Can you image how this would be handled in a typical Hollywood movie?



"Your account is doomed."
The Great and Powerful ZOD

reply

I agree. I admire subtlety in screenplays.

reply

Or maybe it was edited out.

I learned from the commentary that about 1/2 of the film was cut.

Scenes were generally shortened rather than eliminated.

It may be that H & M spoke about the concentration camp.

If they did, it was wisely edited out.




Signature under construction.

reply

IIRC, in the novelization, it does not mention it except when the tattoo is revealed. Even then, it was just in passing.

--
All your base are belong to us.

reply

See Monster Squad for how they deal with it.

--
All your base are belong to us.

reply

Yes. And it was great that the point was so understated.


Definitely understated. I thought maybe they could have done a bit more with this scene to make it stand out a bit more. Like maybe he could have run a few fingers over the tattoo. Then a shot of Maude looking at Harold, maybe giving him a slight smile. The way it was done made it feel like Maude having lived through a concentration camp was almost inconsequential.

reply

This is why you're not a director. That would be godawful and maudlin.

reply

This is why you're not a director. That would be godawful and maudlin.


You're probably right. We wouldn't want the Holocaust or anything connected with it to be shown as unseemly.

reply

This wasn't a WWII movie. I think it was handled perfectly. First, Maude tearfully speaks of her husband Fredrik, and how he was a doctor in the Austrian government. Then later we see the Holocaust tattoo and figure out what happened to poor Fredrik and Maude.

reply

Yes. And it was great that the point was so understated.

Can you image how this would be handled in a typical Hollywood movie?


I know, exactly. It says MORE by explaining less.

Now they would spend a whole 5 minutes elaborating on it so that EVERYONE would get it.


What amazed me about that scene is that I had seen the movie maybe 2-3 times before I even noticed it. (and I had seen those concentration camp tattoos in real life)

reply

Totally missed this, might have noticed it on a big screen.

I've seen this movie twice--once last night and once 20 or 30 years ago. I generally dislike it, though obviously don't outright hate it, or I wouldn't have bothered to see it the second time. But this may make me respect and understand it a bit more.

"I didn't betray you--I simply put a stop to you."

reply