Remake?


Somebody has to start it so it may as well be me. One of the first movies I think I put on VHS back when that was the thing to do. Still got it but am glad to see it broadcast. It would be neat to see a remake although it seems like we don't have the out of the way routes now like we did then. Unless someone was taking a short cut there would be no reason for someone to take such a route on a business trip.

Given the part he recently did on CSI New York or Law and Order SVU, I don't remember which, I think Rob Lowe could do it or maybe make it as a Lifetime movie with a female lead in Dennis Weaver's part. Other possibilities could be Tony Shalhoub, Eric McCormack, or James Gandolfini if he wants to get as far away from Tony Soprano as possible like Dennis Weaver succeeded in getting away from Chester. Good movie.

reply

Over Steven's dead body!!

reply

I can appreciate your opinion and I certainly would not want to see a remake without the blessing and agreement of Mr. Spielberg's since it is his intellectual property. I meant no disrespect toward him.

reply

What i would like to see is if Richard Matheson has any other good short stories, because he is a very good writer in comparison to the hacks today, My quick reaction was more due to the endless remakes, sequels, and prequels, there are so many great stories just sitting on the shelf waiting to be told.

reply

You're right. It is my understanding that remakes, sequels, and prequels have the advantage of being made from a successful product so someone hopes lightning strikes twice. There were the movie serials and movie series of the thirties and forties and later which led to what we have today. Wikipedia is full of stories of movies that were never made or cancelled for one reason or another in addition to unmade stories that you have referenced. I don't know why more of Louis L'Amour's books have not been made into movies.

I am not being morbid or disrespectful but I wish someone could edit and produce "High Jungle". I am sure someone has the print, it may be the heirs of Eric Fleming, or it is a vault somewhere waiting to be re found. It would not be the first "lost" movie found in the vaults. It had to be cancelled when star Eric Fleming was killed doing the last location shot for the movie. I don't blame them for cancelling production. I don't know if they had finished the interior shots and if they had the sound element worked into it. Eric Fleming has a lot of fans who would, out of respect for an almost forgotten and underappreciated actor, appreciate the final project of an actor who's career was on the verge of taking off. He is the reason I enjoy watching Rawhide. Sorry to get on this bunny trail.

reply

Just a clarification, I'm pretty sure Spielberg doesn't own any of the intellectual property for this film. This was a 'for hire' job, I believe.

reply

You are probably right. Everyone has to start somewhere. He created a jewel with this and it showed a genius in the making. I just hope he stays true to himself and stops trying to produce to please Hollywood and remember we here in flyover country enjoy what he is doing. Keep up the good work.

reply

The point about how a remake couldn't possibly work in this day and age of drivers with cell phones and text messaging is exactly the reason why it can't ever be remade credibly. And frankly going to the trouble of making it a period piece would only further beg the question of why bother?

reply

You are very right.Amen. That was a part of American that was fading when Duel was made and is pretty well gone. At least we have that still on film in TV like The Fugitive, Route 66, and other fine movies and TV shows.

I remember they tried to revive Route 66 in the 90's. I thought the stories were pretty good since I grew up with the original but it did not work. I think that type of show cannot work today of someone just taking off to see America and work as they go would be hard to do today. Modern technology, which would keep Duel from being remade, would prevent someone from doing that. They adapted The Fugitive a few years ago to modern technology and it lasted about two years.

reply

Honestly, I think that if there was a remake, that William H. Macy should play in it as Mann, and that it should be a remake still set within the late 1960/early 1970s. The reason for it is because of the fact that a modern day remake would be impossible because people would be asking "Why the hell doesn't this guy have a cellphone, especially if he's a businessman?" or "Why the hell haven't the police picked up this guy when he's killed multiple people with his truck?" and several other questions relating to modern technology and police procedure. By having it be a period piece, it removes those problems out of the equation. But I think William H. Macy is a pretty great actor and he can have the calm businessman demeanor that Mann would require at the start of the movie, and have that animalistic/panicking that he has during the last act.

But alas, I prefer Spielberg's film to not be touched. There's quite a few stories that Matheson has made, some of them being turned into episodes of "The Twilight Zone," and others having not been touched (one I can think of is a story called "Trespass," with a man who starts out suspecting that his wife cheated on him while he was away on military service due to her being pregnant when he wasn't there, only for the baby to turn out to be... Well, I really don't want to spoil it for you).

But this one's eating my popcorn!

reply

I have to agree with you 100%. I would not have thought of William H. Macy but he would be good like he was in Old Dogs and Fargo. Keeping it in the 60's or 70's would also make it work for the reasons that you have listed. Another reason it should be left in that period would be that now he would have no reason to be on such a road for a short cut or getting lost the way the interstates and secondary roads have been built up since then. I am not a trucker but I don't think a lot of truckers would be using such a deserted road due to lack of opportunities of refueling and refreshment due to a lack of business traffic.

In the late 70's, my then wife and I made a trip through Colorado and Utah and took a couple of side trips from the interstate to see what was out there and there was not much there. There were a lot of buildings and gas stations that had closed because the interstates had taken all of the business traffic. I am afraid a lot of the off the beaten track places shown in movies from that time (Duel) and in the shows Route 66, The Fugitive, and Run For Your Life are no longer there because the interstates have now brought us cookie cutter roads with cooking cutter intersections and motels. The America of that era is basically gone. I am sure when the engineers were designing the interstates they never guessed it would kill small a lot of small town America. I appreciate the interstates but we paid a high price for them and not just in dollars.

I lived in a small town in Arkansas as a child during the 50's and early 60's. The interstate bypassed it by about 30 miles and the town has lost about 20% of its population and most of the downtown business buildings are empty. About the only business still there now is the county government. It has become a bedroom community for a larger town about 30 miles away. The interstate did not do it all, changes in commercial patterns and environmental harrassment caused the largest employer, a flooring mill that had been there for over 30 years to close. Someday, I want to take a road trip and not use the interstates to see how much of America from the era of Duel is still there. Sorry I went on so long. Thank you Mr. Speilberg for saving on film a part of America that a lot of us remember and miss.

reply

I'll say this....I love Duel so much that it was a major inspiration to do the film I just shot. It even takes place in 1987. (no I didn't copy Duel)

reply

Good luck and I hope to see it.

reply

Yours is a great and poignant comment. A person made a similar observation about the chase scenes in "It's A Mad Mad Mad Mad World", how he grew up in southern California when the movie was filmed and now all of the roads, except for some of the ones up in the hills, have shopping malls and subdivisions where there used to be open space. Of course, the effect was the exact opposite--booming populations instead of shrinking ones--but still interesting to have read and commented on both perspectives. He even posted a link to a website someone created that used scenes from the movie and photos the website creator shot or found, identifying landmarks to compare what the places looked like past and present.

reply

"It would be neat to see a remake."


What would be really neat if there were never another "remake"
of anything. Sequels, prequels and remakes have ruined the
movie-going experience. Originality is dead when all Hollywood
can do is resurrect old films and old ideas.

reply

Roger Ebert always wondered why they took perfectly good movies (Manchurian Candidate, The Taking of Pelham 1 2 3, etc.) and remade them. They were terrific to begin with. Why not remake a crappy movie and do it better?

reply

Like many others here, I love this movie. However, I might like to see what could be done with it in this day and age as far as a remake.

I think the cell phone issue could be gotten around by having the David Mann character either lose, break or just forget the charger for his phone. And there are still some desolate areas of the West where it wouldn't be out of the question to lose cell service.

I would like to see Mann played by Luke Wilson. Sure, he is known for comedies primarily, but in my opinion, he was very good in "Vacancy". I think he could pull off a suspense thriller.

reply

That is something to think about since we are lost without our cell phones. I can't tell you how many times I have left my house and came back to get mine. I am soon to cut the cord and get rid of my land line. Losing his cell and not having GPS might make it work but why would he be on such a road today like he was then unless he took a short cut and gets lost and then runs afoul of the mad trucker. I am surprised Lifetime has not make a movie of it with a woman in the part of David Man. Years ago, Valerie Harper made a movie similar after Duel. Sad that she if fighting a brain tumor. I hope she receives a miracle and recovers.

reply

A remake would be cool, but it would have to take place in the same era since nowadays, most people have cell phones (with cameras). The feel of being alone and isolated is way less prevalent now. My suggestion for the male lead would be Hugh Laurie...

reply

I could see Bryan Cranston as Mann if they did a remake (which would be unnecessary in my opinion), but William H. Macy would be another good choice.

'I've learned that life is one crushing defeat after another until you just wish Flanders was dead'

reply

I don't think a remake would be a good idea. To many quality films from the 70's and 80's are being remade without having the feeling from the original.
This one still works and is still very effective.
If it isn't broken, don't fix it!

But if a remake was to be produced, I think it would work best if the setting was timeless, ambiguous if you understand.
To not make it a product of a certain era, but make it in a modern retro world. Not to modern but not to 70's either. Like a mixture of both eras.

That could work and be plausible. That could for instance explain why no one has mobile phones.

reply

Listen, I don't know what you're talking about. I live in florida
and there are many places here that if you drive in the middle
of the state that you don't have ANY cell service.
Not only that, I have a MetroPCS phone, that I currently can't afford,
so it is turned off, but if it was on, it only has service in the
city area, when I go too far outside the city, it wont work, even
though there is very good service in these areas for Verizon and
Tmobile, sprint, but MetroPCS is a cheap service because they don't
pay for the cell towers that are out in BFE due to cost.
And don't tell me that people don't use Metro cause it is huge here,
since there isn't much out there in the middle of florida but farmland.
So to your next point about not having anywhere that would be credible
since there are all these interstates, it doesn't hold up here in florida,
I don't know about anywhere else but here the interstates only goe up
and down the coast, and only pass back and forth through the middle
in a couple of spots, so if you need to get to the other coast, and
it is directly over, you might have to drive way out-of-the-way to get
there if you tried to stick to the interstate. that's why most people
would definitely take the smaller state and county roads which we have
many, like webs. and some of them are heavily traveled, but many you
might only see a couple of cars as you drive.But to be sure, if you do take
any of these back ways, your MetroPCS phone wont work.
I for one, like in the Cape Coral area, and you can check it on google
maps, that if I have to drive to Orlando to go to Disney, I do not
drive the interstate, it burns too much gas and it takes longer than
if I drive straight through the middle.



So it is simple, your theory on not being able to do a remake is flawed.
there still many many places in america that your don't want to travel
on and break down on, so they same could go for those same road would
def. be barren enough to have a crazy killer truck, cause if it killed
you, he would get rid of your car and bodies in the back of his trailer
with a winch set up, so the cops would never know what he is up to.
and the cell phone thing is bogus since you can have the best cell phone
in the world, but you get out of your service area then it wont work
and if you are a crazy trucker then you would know all the good spots,
not ever let anybody escape, and if you want to go even further, he could
even have a high-powered cell phone jammer!!!! lol



ok I can't believe I type all this, my fingers hurt now...






http://www.facebook.com/mike.d.keith?ref=profile

reply

You have made a very good case with your observation of isolation. I live in Texas and went to Brownsville one time from Austin. We went through the area around the King Ranch and there is an area there thar really personifies isolation. I agree that there are a lot of area left where someone can get lost and disappear so I still am hoping for a remake. You have shown me that such a project would fly in today's world. I have a hope someday to take a cross country trip and stay off the interstates and see what is left of the real USA. Drive careful.

reply

Be hard to beat West Virginia in a remake in No Cell Phone Coverage or Signal part because its well known all through USA, WV have no cell coverage at all, You lucky get a signal in a major WV city.

Plus our narrow tight steep mountains roads and lots of very sharp 90 or more degree turns on tight mountain roads be nice surprise.

Shoot we have real in no joke life & death Duel play out all day & night long between Auto's & Big loaded Coal Trucks here , And went they hit its always not a pretty picture. Northern Ky good on this point too.

Poor Ole William H. Macy. He get's killed, shot, suicide, beat-up badly, Bubba's cell mate in prison. You name it he always end up on the losing side of all his movies. If they a award for most picked on movie actor in a major movie every year his wall be full of awards.

reply

It wouldn't work because all he'd have to do is call the cops on his cellphone.

reply

I would like to see Bryan Cranston in a Remake.

reply

Please, no! Hasn't Hollywood already butchered enough classics? The mobile phone issue is a blessing, as most audiences won't look past it and therefore it won't work... phew!



reply

You could just set the movie in another time period to avoid the mobile phone issue.

reply

I' say this before and say it again: A remake would work if it's set in a ambiguous setting. Not exactly of today but not from the 70's either. To not set it in a specific era. That would benefit a potential remake.

Of course a more fun idea is to make the main character total opposite from the original? Why not a woman? A Mrs Mann? Being per-sued by a crazy female truck-driver? Role reverses are always interesting:)

Or maybe a young person as opposed to someone older? Or East Coast as opposed to West Coast?
Might be fun.

reply

I tend to agree about NOT making a re-make, this is a classic and should be appreciated as it is.. On a side note, another classic 'on the road in isolation' type movie I also love is Hitcher (1986), sadly this was re-made and IMO stunk. Sean Bean, who is a great actor, just never felt as menacing as Rutger Hauer. So I agree that trying to re-make Duel would probably be a sad failure..

reply