MovieChat Forums > Duel (1971) Discussion > What an insane cop-out to not give an en...

What an insane cop-out to not give an ending


While I like movies with unresolved questions, this film most certainly needed an explanation at the end. You can't have some crazy driver try to kill someone for 90 mins with no sense or purpose...and then nothing. That's just cheating the audience.

reply

What was the Zodiac killer's purpose? We don't know. Sometimes we don't know why crazy people do what they do and we're left without explanations.

Besides, did you want the driver to explain his sense of purpose as he was heading down the cliff? I guess he could've shouted it out the window as he was going over. "I hate red cAAAAaaaaaaaarrrrrrsssss....."

reply

Besides, did you want the driver to explain his sense of purpose as he was heading down the cliff? I guess he could've shouted it out the window as he was going over. "I hate red cAAAAaaaaaaaarrrrrrsssss....."

Your comment cracks me up!





If God has a master plan that only He understands, I hope it's your eyes he's seeing through. - Martin Gore, Depeche Mode

reply

😀

reply

Besides, did you want the driver to explain his sense of purpose as he was heading down the cliff? I guess he could've shouted it out the window as he was going over. "I hate red cAAAAaaaaaaaarrrrrrsssss....."


I've laughed a lot on that too... thanks! 😀

reply

[deleted]

Very funny and well put




"It's ok to play with dolls!"

reply

Spielberg's intention, as was Richard Matheson's intention when he did the short story and the screenplay, was to tell a tale of a cat and mouse game. We don't need to know why the truck driver does what he does. All we know is that he's insane, and he has killed others in the same way he tried to kill David Mann. It's a story of survival, not a serial killer thriller where there has to be a method to to the madness.

 But this one's eating my popcorn!

reply

Did you expect him to walk down to the wreckage and ask the corpse of the driver, "Why?" Or maybe the ghost of the driver will appear in front of him and explain himself. I was waiting for him to drive off, look in the mirror, and see that same truck behind him, indicating that it was a demon truck, sent straight from hell, to torture little red cars.

reply

People get into road rage situations all the time and there's no deep explanation. This one was just extreme.

reply

It's all tied in to the radio at the beginning. The truck driver is actually the guy who phones into the radio show saying he plays meat. He was pursuing Mann to harvest his 'meat flute'. Obvious, really.

reply

You can't have some crazy driver try to kill someone for 90 mins with no sense or purpose...and then nothing. That's just cheating the audience.


Naw, man, that's just embodying the randomness of life. Dig it.

If Spielberg and company HAD given some 'explanation', it would have been too pat, too tidy, and lots of us would have found fault with the particular 'reason' provided. Somehow they sensed that in a few decades there would be these things called 'message boards' and people would be criticizing their 'explanation'-- so they said, "Wouldn't it be better for people to just wonder?" And, yes, it IS better that way-- as a mystery.

That's what Weaver is doing while he's sitting there and the sun is gradually going down-- he's wondering why all of that stuff happened to him. We're being invited to empathize with him by sharing his frustration about not knowing the answer... at least until the credits end and the local ABC station reminds us the 11:00 news is next.

reply

While I like movies with unresolved questions


Apparently you don't

this film most certainly needed an explanation at the end.


No it didn't

You can't have some crazy driver try to kill someone for 90 mins with no sense or purpose...and then nothing. That's just cheating the audience.


It would have been cheating the audience to explain everything. Without an explanation, without really seeing him, he's so much more mysterious and creepy. It serves to make the truck almost a monster instead of just the tool of some uptight trucker's road rage. The mystery of the trucker and his intentions is exactly what makes the movie so great.

See you guys at the 10 year prison reunion - Ben Richards

reply

[deleted]