MovieChat Forums > Dirty Harry (1971) Discussion > Did anyone else find parts disturbing?

Did anyone else find parts disturbing?


I don't get disturbed easily, and even after seeing this several times some parts still bother me. It looks like a typical action movie from the posters, trailers, etc., but it has some intense parts.

For me the most disturbing part is when Scorpio pays the black guy to beat him up and calls him the N word to make it worse. It's not necessarily graphic or anything but just the idea of him paying someone to beat him up is really messed up.

Also the whole idea of innocent people getting targeted for no reason, the young girl being abducted, raped and put in a hole to die and the young boy getting shot as well. The bus scene at the end was fairly unsettling too. This movie definitely had some disturbing elements that stayed with me.

reply

[deleted]

lol all the things the Scorpio did and you're bitching about Callahan?!

You want to play the game, you'd better know the rules, love.
-Harry Callahan

reply

Dirty Harry was not called Dirty Harry because he was a bad cop. He got every Dirty Job that came down the pike. His partner explains that I think in the jumper scene.
L

reply

'paying the black Guy scene' was pointed out in the commentary of the film. It was certainly unusual and not particularly a good sequence in the movie.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I have seen this many many times. Usually when I find a part of a movie that disturbs me I get over it after two or three viewings. But the scene where he pays the black dude to beat him up is one I also find disturbing, so I tend not to watch when it is on.

It's the only part of the film that particularly bothers me. Yes Harry is a dirty cop and appeals to a real right-wing state of mind. He often bends the law, or steps right outside it, but like a lot of Harry symnpathisers, I take the view that he does what is necessary to get the job done. Part of me feels I should be disturbed by the scene on the ground at Kieza (sp?) Stadium but it doesn't bother me. Scorpio had it coming, imo.

When I said I wanted to be a comedian, they all laughed at me. Well, they're not laughing now!

reply

[deleted]

Lol no kidding

reply

The disturbing parts in DH are the very reason why it's such a landmark film.

It set the standard for every crime drama that proceeded it.

I remember my parents going to see DH when I was nine years old.

They loved it, but told me years later a lot of vocally angry patrons walked out when Scorpio took the school bus.

That film still shakes people up.

reply

I just watched the film, and I don't recall hearing the N-word, but rather heard him say you black son of a bitch, not that it's much nicer.

reply

I saw the film Dirty Harry when it first came out, and have seen it afew times since, but not only did I hear Scorpio calling the black bartender a "black son of a bitch", but, at one point in the film, even before that, Scorpio left the SFPD a note explicitly using the N-word, about the next person that he planned to kill.

I, too found the football field scene rather creepy, and the fact that Harry, just generally constantly went to excesses and didn't respect the right of criminals to have counsel, and to have fair trials was also rather unnerving.

The bus scene was also rather unnerving, and I had no doubt that Scorpio would've shot up and killed everybody on that bus, including the woman who drove the bus if they didn't comply or cooperate with him in any way.

Overall, however, I found the fact that Harry had blown the chance to bring a dangerous serial killer (i. e. "Scorpio") to justice before the law, and to possibly have him put away behind bars for life without parole, due to Harry's excesses, rather bothersome, not because I sympathized with Scorpio, but because it caused undue suffering for everybody on the long run, and it proved that cops sometimes violate the laws that they have sworn to uphold, and degrade the people that they've sworn to protect.


reply

I, too found the football field scene rather creepy, and the fact that Harry, just generally constantly went to excesses and didn't respect the right of criminals to have counsel, and to have fair trials was also rather unnerving.

The bus scene was also rather unnerving, and I had no doubt that Scorpio would've shot up and killed everybody on that bus, including the woman who drove the bus if they didn't comply or cooperate with him in any way.

Overall, however, I found the fact that Harry had blown the chance to bring a dangerous serial killer (i. e. "Scorpio") to justice before the law, and to possibly have him put away behind bars for life without parole, due to Harry's excesses, rather bothersome, not because I sympathized with Scorpio, but because it caused undue suffering for everybody on the long run, and it proved that cops sometimes violate the laws that they have sworn to uphold, and degrade the people that they've sworn to protect.


I'm surprised no one has responded before to this bit - the film makes it clear repeatedly he wasn't doing it because of his excesses or because he was some kind of fascist thug, he was doing it because he wanted to get the girl's location as quickly as possible to save her.

reply

I found the football field scene a little creepy, hearing Scorpio's mentally unhinged scream sends a shiver down my spine.

"Stop looking at the walls, look out the window." ~ Karl Pilkington On Art

reply

In regards to Scorpio and everybody like him.Why do some people always defend people like that?

You want to play the game, you'd better know the rules, love.
-Harry Callahan

reply

Same reason they sympathize with cop killers on the loose like Chris Dorner, it's bizarre.

Y'know, I could eat a peach for hours

reply

Andrew Robinson (Scorpio) did an incredible job of portraying a completely psychotic, but very well controlled individual. The scene where he is beaten up was done simply to show how far he was willing to go to get back at Harry. It was a means to an end. The bus scene is very difficult (gut-wrentching actually) to watch. It was so done so realistically, that you really had an even deeper hatred for Scorpio by the time he has the showdown with Harry. (I recall while all the kids were singing, the chubby kid cried out, "I want my mommy!" Scorpio turned toward him with no hesitation and growled, "Shut-up!")
I remember reading that after the film opened, Andrew Robinson (who is one of the most kind, gentle and unassuming guys there is in Hollywood) had to change his phone number several times, as was getting death threats regularly from movie-goers! That is a testament to what a powerful performance that was.

reply

[deleted]

I think Andrew Robinson did an excellent job of portraying a totally psychotic but controlled (and dangerous) serial killer too, badmilly. The fact that he looked so much like an altar-boy or choir-boy made him even more convincing!

reply

If I recall correctly, the first time I saw the film (which was on TV) the scene where Scorpio pays the mercenary to beat him up was censored - the scene faded out after the first few punches were thrown.

Personally I found the scene of the girl's naked corpse being pulled out of the hole in the ground more haunting.

reply

I was disturbed when they pulled the naked teenaged girls body out of the hole.

reply

Nobody finds offensive the depiction of a dead naked teenage female corpse being pulled out of her crypt ...? That wasn't sufficiently offensive? That scene alone comes close to a sub-genre of porn not readily acceptable by most people...

reply

It's supposed to be disturbing in that way. You have to put this film into historical perspective.....this movie came out just a few years after the Miranda ruling, and at a time when a lot of folks were getting off for 'police brutality' in a time when officers were not trained as they are today.

The whole idea is to show Scorpio as being the most sadistic and despicable of criminals.....a predatory animal, really.....so the audience will not identify with him on any level. This way, when you hear all the talk about his 'rights,' instead of sympathizing with Scorpio, you are enraged that he is using this system to stay free, and continue to torture and murder.

The bad news is you have houseguests. There is no good news.

reply

Yes! Seeing a naked and dead 14 yr old girl (played by 18 yr old Debra Lee Scott) pulled out of the ground is highly disturbing. The fact that Zodiac (who Scorpio was based on) targeted and threatened children is quite sick. After the school bus takeover, you're 100% ready to have Harry blow his brains out.

reply

For me the most disturbing part is when Scorpio pays the black guy to beat him up and calls him the N word to make it worse. It's not necessarily graphic or anything but just the idea of him paying someone to beat him up is really messed up.

--

I will date myself. I saw Dirty Harry first run at the theater in 1971. With my father. I was maybe a little too young for some of that disturbing material, but overall, I loved the excitement and action of the movie, and so did my father.

But we BOTH freaked out, and creeped out, and looked at each other nervously as that scene with the black guy appeared. Its no fun for a father and son to have to experience such a creepy scene together.

Here's the thing: I thought as it first developed -- and the black guy put the rubber glove on -- that we were about to experience some sort of SEX scene. And what's creepy is that, as the scene proceeds, it rather IS like a "violent" version OF a sex session between a man and a hooker. Scorpio asks "for his money's worth" -- gets it -- and then proceeds to insult the black man near the end. Which leads to more brutality from the black man as he kicks Scorpio and says "this one is on the house." Again, the transactional nature of the scene suggests a sex for money scene.

Scorpio's mangled, blood mask of a face in this scene was creepy, too. Time Magazine did an article on "violence in the movies" and used a photo of Andy Robinson's face here to make their case for "ultra-violence is here."

reply