Blonde2291,
I think you are confused with what the words reverence and worshiping means. Those of us who enjoyed the film do not worship it; well, maybe some do, so I can't speak for them. And if those same people post about their enjoyment, how is that any different from you posting your dislike of it? Don't make yourself out to be the victim by playing this card, like you are being attacked for no reason; this is an open discussion, one that you created.
Moving on...
Your original post was this:
I have watched B movies and badly scripted movies, but THX1138 is worst of them all. I can understand why it was not liked in 1971. A nightmare of the worst kind.
As I pointed out, along with others, this kind of drive-by commentary isn't going to win you points; it certainly isn't going to make people think you are actually providing any real criticism. Honestly, what kind of responses were you hoping to get? Were you expecting to have a bunch of haters jump on your bandwagon? Maybe you were just trolling?
Any ways, it now seems as if you are backtracking:
I expressed my honest opinion and I still believe that this is a very depressing, bleak and boring movie. Story development is very slow and it looks like a documentary for most of the time leaving the viewer wondering - what the hell is happening.
Unfortunately those are two very different opinions of the film, yet they are both yours. So which is it? Is this movie still a nightmare and the worst of its kind, or is it depressing and boring? If it's the latter then refer to my other response about viewers who use the word "boring" to describe films. The fact that you even say "what the hell is happening" confirms what I said about your original post:
When people only see the surface of what they are examining, or in this case what they are being entertained by, and are only willing to stay within the confines of their own ego-driven intelligence, then of course things will be 'boring.' When this mindset is applied to a film like this, these people will ignorantly declare that 'there's no other story line' because they were unwilling and unable to look any deeper.
Even if you refuse to take into consideration that this film has layers of meaning, e.g. that is uses Plato's Allegory of the Cave, at least think about its historical context. Think about 1971 and how topical this film really was. I can assure you that the social commentary isn't boring using this lens, and it wasn't that far from reality; the fact that this film can be still be relatable by today's standards is pretty amazing.
And as far as people not liking this movie when it was released, again you have understand the history of what was happening during its release. The hippies/revolutions/Zeitgeists/etc were coming to an end. The people who would have likely embraced the film and its messages were abandoning their stations, and literally growing up; they didn't want the cultural associations anymore. Charles Manson destroyed whatever remaining peace and love that was left with his murderous cult, and everything basically went mainstream. It's no wonder why this film wasn't a success—it reflected the many realities of the time too well. And in 1977 the studio tried to re-release it because of Lucas' success with Star Wars; however, once again the movie failed because nobody cared about some bleak, depressing film about the future. They'd rather see lightsabers and wookies.
reply
share