MovieChat Forums > Santa Claus Is Comin' to Town (1970) Discussion > Burgermeister should have been reformed!

Burgermeister should have been reformed!


I sometimes think there should have been a climactic resolution where the Burgermeister realized the error of his ways, and turned to the good side like Winter Warlock. The yo-yo scene (where his bliss was interrupted by Grimsley's Mephistophelean whisper) indicates that this was a possibility. Burgo's character arc wasn't really resolved, the picture simply flashes forward to a time when he's out of office.

But maybe that would have complicated the story too much and distracted the focus from Claus?

reply

I don't agree. I think they did it right in this. They had already shown the Winter Warlock being reformed which in my opinion was enough. It is showing that some people simply can't be reformed.



He's taking the knife out of the Cheese!
Do you think he wants some cheese?


reply

Herr burgermeister, herr bugermeister! Let it be decreed from sea to sea, THERE WILL BE NO MORE TOY MAKERS TO THE KIIIIIINNNNNNNNGGGGGGGGG!!!!

reply

[deleted]

Yeah, Grimsby (however you spell it) acted like a jerk there. But I guess the point was that some people don't change no matter what. At the end, we see modern day versions of Burgermeister as well, who don't like Christmas. As to what happened to B, he eventually died and went to hell, which is signified with his picture falling off the wall and being thrown in the garbage where it belonged.

reply

I think the Burgermeister get's a bad rap! Those kid's WERE brats and should have all been taken to the orphanage where they belong! Just kidding...the B-meister got what he deserved.

"I was feeling well enough to eat the pears." -Lizzy Borden

reply

Kris tried to reform the Burgermeister. He was given a yo-yo, and for a moment he was changed. Then he realized he was breaking his own law and went back to his bad habits.

The Burgermeister chose to act that way. He could have been like Winter or Jessica. Except he didn't want to. Which I think is an important lesson to show kids. Not all people are good or can change.

Josh

reply

Had Grimsley not intervened during the yo-yo moment, would the Burgermeister have reformed, or would he have resumed his evil as soon as the initial novelty wore off?

reply

I'm thinking if the Burgermeister could revert to his evil ways so easily, it's impossible for him to stay reformed.

Josh

reply

I guess it's harder to put one foot in front of the other when one of them is all bandaged up.

reply

I understand he had gout.



IMDb no longer gets my endorsement.

reply

I'm old enough to have seen the original version, which was more of a "Rudolph" cross-over. In the original version there's an epilogue scene during the closing credits in which the kids ask the Fred Astaire character, "So what happened to the Burgomeister?" and Fred chuckles and says (with a wink to the audience, "Oh, he was paid a visit by a friend of mine from the North Pole, and was persuaded to 'retire.'" We see the Burgomeister hear a knock on his palace door one night, and he says, "Who is it is thise hour?"

The door opens and in comes a bearded, lumberjack-type person driving a dog sled with a bundle on it. "Ta-dahh!" the newcomer announces. "It's Yukon Cornelius--in person! And I have a Christmas present for you!" He kicks the bundle off the sled and the Burgomeister gleefully unwraps it--only to find his chief of staff dead, with his Junker-style spiked helmet driven through his heart.

"What is this?" the Burgomeister asks horrified.

"A message from Santa," Yukon says.

"What . . . message?"

"This," Yukon Cornelius says, whipping the six-shooter from his belt and pointing it the Burgomeister's head. "Santa thinks you've been very naughty, so instead of a toy he sends you a little lead. Ho-ho-ho!" And he shoots the Burgomeister right between the eyes.

Some parents and media m,watchdog groups protested the scene as too violent and it was taken out for later airings.

reply

Great re-imagining of a MAD TV Rudolph/Godfather/Goodfellas parody that ran about twenty years ago.

reply

One of my favorite comments ever on this point: Santa did not defeat the Bugermiester. He just waited for him to die.

All glory to the Hypnotoad

reply

Yes and some people have to die

reply