MovieChat Forums > Kelly's Heroes (1970) Discussion > Oddball may have been odd, but...

Oddball may have been odd, but...


in spite of his goofy persona, he was an effective tank commander, the way he coordinated the attack on the Germans at the train station, also in the town.

reply

What did he coordinate? The personnel at the train station were made up of infantry. They had no armour so three Sherman's even with a blind slow coach in command could have wiped it out and I was always under the impression it was Joe with the 'head for tactics' and Kelly leading the assault that accomplished the raid on Clermont.

If you dip your foot into a pool of piranhas don't cry when you lose a toe!😞🐟

reply

Co-ordination?
They just shot everything in site.

"CG is good. CG works" Gordon Ghekko

reply

I think you're right- he was basically a good tanker. But when his CO got killed he and the guys just wanted to take a bit of down time. But he wasn't crazy or a coward. As Big Joe said Oddball would still be back on his funny farm if he knew there were Tigers at the town with the bank. I just loved how they hid out behind the supply depot with the women and wine and pigs roasting. They were just playing the system like Crapgame and Mulligan and everybody else was (Maitland's yacht?).

reply