Spare, tragic movie


Peck holds it in throughout most of the movie. We feel his dissatisfaction and his discomfort. He's so tightly wound it's frightening. The movie plays squarely on his shoulders and I thought his performance brave, at times even shocking. Frankenheimer directs with such a sure and simple hand. He visually focuses on characters moving though this terribly decayed environment. Everything is dead or dying. The only beauty we are entitled to here is the natural setting. But even that is sullied by poverty that seems frozen in time. Frankenheimer's film is really about the environment and how it distills hopelessness and despair. The way his camera lovingly glides across the colorless wooden porch jutting out from a long abandoned house where Peck takes Tuesday Weld you know that what's happening has no future. The spare, single minded storytelling here is probably why the film is such a lost gem. There's no hope; not even a glimmer of something good. Only decay. Peck's final moments are the most disturbing scenes he ever played. In some ways it's like watching Jimmy Stewart loose it at the end of VERTIGO, except in this film our main character never gets close to what he wants. This is not a happy movie, but it is a very good one.

reply

Well said Faust. For not saying much in the movie, Peck sure said a lot. Even sitting at the dinner table.

reply

Thank-you.

reply

No one mentions Estelle Parson's role in this film...she plays Peck's wife, Ellen, and she knows something is going on but doesn't know what...he won't talk to her about it when she questions him and the mental anguish she goes thru is heart-rending.
She always gave a wonderful performance and she does in this one, as well.

One wants to smack the very smug Charles Durning..I think he has designs on the Sheriff's job and he watches him like a hawk, waiting to get something on him.



"If you can make a girl laugh, you can make her do anything!"....


reply

well put nfaust, especially your head, "spare, tragic movie" says it all.

reply

I have read that this movie had incestuous scenes in it. Where were they?

reply

I first saw this movie on late night television a few months ago. I loved the movie, but was a little disturbed when it suggested incest between Alma and her pappy as he crawled into bed with her (fully clothed). I got the DVD from Amazon recently and watched it, and I did not sense the cold prickly feeling I had gotten originally. I think the DVD must have been edited. Something else seemed amiss, but I can't put my finger on it. I will have to try to catch it on T.V. again and see what's up.

reply

It didn’t strike me as tragic. Sparse, sure.
But worlds were illuminated, paths were taken, and maybe some roads were forsaken, that’s life.

reply

cowplop^

"For not saying much in the movie, Peck sure said a lot. Even sitting at the dinner table."

I know!

Did you see his expression while thinking back on his first interactions with Alma, earlier in the day, while he was at the dinner table after his daughter told the parrot joke?

That is some fine acting!

How I yearn for the days when movie makers and actors could convey so much so economically ~




"I can't stand a naked light bulb, any more than..a rude remark or a vulgar action" Blanche DuBois

reply

thank you for your comments. I've just recently got my hands on this film after wanting to see it for so long (I'm a big fan of Peck and Frankenheimer). Will let you know my opinion on it this evening.

reply

nfaust1 - beautifully said.

I loved the movie for all the same reasons in how you described it. The sense of hopelessness & poverty & decay. The movie was interesting & captivated me from start till finish and I think this is one of Peck's finest performances - so much of his performance was silent, but the viewer knows exactly what he's feeling all the time as loud as anything. One of the best films I've seen in awhile, and I watch a lot of movies!


"Are you going to your grave with unlived lives in your veins?" ~ The Good Girl

reply

nfaust1^

Years later I just simply had to re-post your stunning comments -- they are so eloquent, insightful and hit the heart of this wonderful film superbly well (although I would have to add that the only beauty is not the natural setting in this film: there is also the physical beauty of Weld and the spiritual beauty of Parson's character as the wife :)

"Peck holds it in throughout most of the movie. We feel his dissatisfaction and his discomfort. He's so tightly wound it's frightening. The movie plays squarely on his shoulders and I thought his performance brave, at times even shocking. Frankenheimer directs with such a sure and simple hand. He visually focuses on characters moving though this terribly decayed environment. Everything is dead or dying. The only beauty we are entitled to here is the natural setting. But even that is sullied by poverty that seems frozen in time. Frankenheimer's film is really about the environment and how it distills hopelessness and despair. The way his camera lovingly glides across the colorless wooden porch jutting out from a long abandoned house where Peck takes Tuesday Weld you know that what's happening has no future. The spare, single minded storytelling here is probably why the film is such a lost gem. There's no hope; not even a glimmer of something good. Only decay. Peck's final moments are the most disturbing scenes he ever played. In some ways it's like watching Jimmy Stewart loose it at the end of VERTIGO, except in this film our main character never gets close to what he wants. This is not a happy movie, but it is a very good one."

Bravo!



"I can't stand a naked light bulb, any more than..a rude remark or a vulgar action" Blanche DuBois

reply

Am touched by your compliment. Thank-you. Nick

reply

Did anyone else notice how Frankenheimer
uses split diopter shots like crazy in this
movie?

reply

IceboxMovies, actually no, I didn't. But it doesn't surprise me. Frankenheimer always talks about his preference for using wide angle lens in his commentaries; he liked sharp depth of field. Will look out for this the next time I see the movie. Thank-you.

reply

I agree - great, underrated movie! Peck's strengths as an actor really power this movie through to its conclusion, as do the talents of the other actors, the way the movie is shot, and the perfect soundtrack.

My real name is Jeff

reply