MovieChat Forums > Husbands (1970) Discussion > finally the UNcut version is on DVD

finally the UNcut version is on DVD


http://www.amazon.com/Husbands-Extended-Cut-Ben-Gazzara/dp/B0024FAG2Q/ref=pd_sim_v_1

"That's quite a humor you have." --John Cassavetes' Husbands

reply

Close, but only in a sense. The new Sony DVD clocks in at 142 minutes, compared to 154' at the SF Festival, 138' in its theatrical release, and 131' in its TV cut. So at least we're getting more than what 1970 theater audiences saw.

This may be a situation similar to The Killing of a Chinese Bookie, which Cassavetes recut from 135' to 108' for its 1978 rerelease. (Both versions of Chinese Bookie are available from Criterion, for comparison).


In any case, for whatever it might be worth, I never trust the corporate suits at Sony. When they bought Columbia's huge catalog of music and films they had no concept of the artistic value of what they were sitting on, and an enormous number of incomparably important musical performances are still stashed away rotting in their vaults. And they pretty much destroyed David Lean's Lawrence of Arabia by gratuitously cutting out the Bey's rape of Lawrence up in his back office, after the beating on the bench and before Lawrence is thrown out into the street - this crucial scene took less than a minute of run time in the film's original theatrical release. So now there is considerable confusion among viewers as to whether a rape ever occurred. The problem is that you need this information to better understand Lawrence's subsequent frame of mind.

reply

Criminy, there is more? The ramnling, shifting, meandering version we get now has neen trimmed/ can't wait to see teh pauses left out of teh "cut" version

reply

Word is that Gena Rowlands made them cut the remaining 12 minutes out of the DVD because she found it to be "inappropriate and distasteful". Who knows what to believe, though.

reply

Okay, hopefully this will clear up some of the issues on the DVD version of "Husbands", though I'm going by memory and somebody like Ray Carney would probably be able to provide more insight...

The version which premiered at the San Francisco Film Festival was 154 minutes. As far as I've read, this version was only publicly screened at the festival.

The 141 (or 142) minute version is the general release version. Columbia's contract restricted the finished film from running any longer, which is why there are no closing credits. That's also why the credits are all crammed onto the two opening cards -- that way he had to cut as little of the film as possible.

The later 131 (and 139, I think) minute versions are "restorations". These did include "cuts" of footage which were deemed "distasteful", but also included a brief shot or two which didn't make it into the general release version.

So, as far as I know, the current DVD release should be complete. One way to tell the difference, if I remember, is that the later "cut" versions didn't include "Buddy, Can You Spare A Dime" being sung in the bar.

Of course, if anybody can add to/correct this information, please feel free to do so. I'm going from my memory of reading "Cassavetes on Cassavetes"

Kevin

reply


Its the kinda film that takes you a while to get into and then when you do, you don't want it to end...


"ah have always depended upon the strangeness of kindness..."

reply

[deleted]