MovieChat Forums > Catch-22 (1970) Discussion > Scared to watch the movie

Scared to watch the movie


My favorite book of all time. All time. I read it every year. I don't want it ruined by watching the movie. Will I be dissapointed, angered, pleased?

www.notjustabasketballplayer.com

reply

Well, the movie is different.

It's not done by the book - it's almost impossible, as it's a 600+ pages book with a lot of episodes and too many characters.
About two-thirds of the book's characters were not in the film, and some reduced to bit parts (or reduced to bits, like Hungry Joe).

No Lieutenant Scheisskopf marching around, no Major ...DeCoverley, no Chief White Halfoat, for example.
The entire bureaucratic fight of General Peckem with ex-P.F.C.Wintergreen is omitted - Gen Driddle is played by Orson Wells and it's the only general around.
And most detalied description of fellow pilots or personnel in the base is largely omitted or reduced.

And the end of the movie depart, somehow, from the book's finale.
More in style than in story, to be honest.


Still, the movie has its merit.
It catch the "catchy" mood of the book, and it's an interesting piece of cinema art. Montage, style, and use of the camera need a look, to me.

I liked the book, and I liked the movie.

reply

Additional footage was shot of Hungry Joe as played by an uncredited Seth Allen. Upon meeting Nichols for the first time Allen performed a pratfall which caused Nichols to chuckle, either sincerely or insincerely only Mike knows if he even remembers the incident. Alas, something transpired between the two and Seth was fired. Glimpses of him remain in the film since these scenes are integral but do create a bit of a mystery. And who can forget the scene where Hungry Joe gets chopped in half.

reply

Heller himself was an admirer of the film, so I'm not sure why any literary fan of the book, wouldn't wish to see this movie.🐭

reply

I thought it was very heavy-handed and overly emotional. Hard to take seriously. I don't recommend it- EVEN IF you happened to like the book.

reply

I've been reading the book for the last forty years and love it very much. ----- And I've watched the movie just about once a year in those very same forty years and absolutely enjoy it everytime. ----- And there are so many classic parts of the book that I feel should of been included in the movie, just one of all of those, is on page 177 when Yossarian starts a dialog about all things that are out to kill him. All of the people he mentions and then every living cell in his body is out to kill him by various diseases. A very funny part of the book. ----- And after all these years I can only appreciate Alan Arkin's great performance playing Yossarian, nobody else could ever match him if a remake of the movie was ever done. ----- ----- Rusty


"On screen Winona stands out like a polar bear on black velvet" Timothy Leary about his Goddaughter

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

I love the book mightily, and I think this is a brilliant film adaptation. ADAPTATION. It isn't the book, it's a film adaptation. And it's a brilliant one.

reply

Brilliant film. Not to be missed.

reply