What does the title mean?


Is it something explained in the book that never made it to the movie?

reply


Is it something explained in the book that never made it to the movie?


Yes. It is the title of a short, heartbroken poem written and recited by Pookie in the novel at or near the point of the couple's breakup. You can find a transcription of it on the "bloopers" thread.

reply

Thanks so much for the reply!

reply

[deleted]

I'm watching it now too.. Brilliant film, I can't believe I've never heard of it before.

reply

Thora, it's very rarely shown, unfortunately. So I make it a point to catch it whenever it's on.

I set up a TCM email reminder so I wouldn't forget this time :)




God save Donald Duck, vaudeville and variety

reply

I saw this movie when it first came out (and I was a freshman in college), and I really liked it. It's the only thing I've ever liked Liza Minnelli in--normally I can't abide her--but she was great in this. Watching Pookie was like watching an impending train wreck. She made you cringe with embarrassment for her, and that was what the writers intended, so she acted the part very well.

reply

It's true that this doesn't get shown very often. I've watched it twice recently, the first time since I saw it in the theater! Yet, I remembered all of it and how much it seemed so much more on the level than most of Hollywood's takes on the teen and college scenes.

What's even rarer is "Tell Me That You Love Me, Junie Moon". That one has faded in my memory somewhat. If they start showing "The Sterile Cuckoo", perhaps we'll start seeing more Sixties and early Seventies films, which truly have been neglected. I was so surprised to see "Breezy" showing up, as well as one that never showed anywhere around here: "Wonderwall", with music by George Harrison.

I'm hoping that they will begin routinely showing some of the wonderful movies from that era. This one certainly has held up beautifully and is as heartbreaking as it was then. I hadn't seen anything approaching its tale of lost love until I saw "I Love You, I Love You Not", starring Claire Danes and Jude Law. Claire's Daisy is nearly as agonized as Liza's Pookie, neither one able to change herself enough to keep the boy she loves. *SIGH*

reply

How does one set up a TCM reminder?

I would desperately like to have this service.

reply

"About 56 of the Old World species and 3 of the New World species are brood parasites, laying their eggs in the nests of other birds. The best-known example is the European Common Cuckoo. The cuckoo egg hatches earlier than the host's, and the cuckoo chick grows faster; in most cases the chick evicts the eggs or young of the host species. The chick has no time to learn this behavior, so it must be an instinct passed on genetically. The mother still feeds the cuckoo chick as if it were her own, the chick's open mouth serving as a sign stimulus for the host to feed it." - from Wikipedia

This strikes me as similar to Pookie's situation. Abandoned by her parents in a "nest" where she doesn't belong, she desperately opens her mouth in the hope of being "fed" with affection. Eventually, she finds someone like Jerry who's willing to take her "under his wing," but then she tries to evict anyone who gets between them, like Charlie, by branding them "weirdos." In the end, though, Jerry is forced to evict Pookie from the nest, lest she take over his life completely.

The "sterile" part of the title has multiple levels of meaning, I think. The most common meaning is "sexually infertile," and so there's the obvious parallel of Pookie's false pregnancy, with its suggestion that her fantasy springs from her inability to have kids of her own -- or, perhaps, simply from a cuckoo-like inability to take responsibility for them. "Sterile" can also mean "free from bacteria," and no doubt Pookie sees herself as uninfected by the sickness of the "weirdos" around her. But "sterile" has yet another meaning: "lacking in imagination or vitality, not stimulating." At first glance, this doesn't seem to apply to Pookie at all, and no doubt she'd rather die than admit that her life might be sterile in this way -- but by the end of the film, it's clear that this is just what she fears she really is, and that there is some reason for her fear. And as the film concludes, Pookie's mental illness has tragically brought her to the final dictionary definition of "sterile" -- i.e., "lacking any power to function, not productive or effective."

reply

The previous poster makes several excellent observations, and I really loved reading this analysis, which teases many of the same levels of meaning from the title which I had entertained at one time or another. I am convinced that John Nichols-- who often demonstrates a very sincere interest and erudition in nature and zoology-- had at least a few of these metaphorical considerations in mind when he had Pookie describe herself tragically through poetry as "a sterile cuckoo." That that connection to the novel remains totally unexplained by the movie adapatation is more than a little awkward, in my opinion.

Nice post.

reply

Thanks for one of the most cogent, insightful posts I've read on anything.

reply

I just thought it was from a poem she wrote (according to the book).

RIP Heath Ledger 1979-2008

reply


This is a wonderful breakdown, and I thank you for posting it. I would only add that novel-Jerry is apparently sterile himself, in sexual terms, as implied by Pookie's reassurances to her friend Nancy Putnam late in the book after Jerry has tried to make it with her.

reply

wow bkamberger what an insightful post! You summed up so well insights I hadn't been able to fully formulate on this meaning. I love it!

reply