How Good Is it?


This movie was broadcasted late at night on TV in my hometown years ago, my late mom really liked it. Any other opinions.

reply

i love this movie. I love Patty Duke but I really love the era that it captures of Greenwich Village in the late 60's

reply

I saw it in Philly when it was first released. A friend and I passed the line for Easy Rider and saw Me, Natalie, instead! Yes, the era was interesting. Her apartment had a sofa made out of an old bathtub with the side cut out and a big pillow placed inside.

"Two more swords and I'll be Queen of the Monkey People." Roseanne

reply

that's how good it is, great acting



When there's no more room in hell, The dead will walk the earth...

reply

Fair, at best. It's not really compelling, and tries too hard to be of its era. Duke's make up, false nose & buck teeth are distrracting;they didn't have to make her Ugly Betty. The film lacks focus & pacing, and supporting characters such as those played by Martin Balsam and Salome Jems don't add anything. The film was released and forgotten. The film loses interest as it goes on. More of a curio now than anything else. Duke's 1972 film You'll Like My Mother is far more entertaining and it deserves a DVD release.

reply

Oh I totally disagree! "You'll Like My Mother" is a formula distress thriller, but "Me, Natalie" is something extra special, well-written and often achingly lovely. Martin Balsam (playing Natalie's beloved uncle who praises his niece's inner beauty, then turns around and marries a buxom bombshell) is terrific, and the relationship between the two is extraordinary. James Farentino has never been shown to such a good advantage since, and Patty Duke...well, what can you say about her? She's so in the moment, so pity and real, that you hang onto every word she says. A wonderful, unique picture.

reply

"... an artificial mess of wisecracks and sentimentality"
-Vincent Canby
NY Times 7/14/1969

reply

Canby can always be counted on to miss the point.

reply

"Me, Natalie" is a pleasant film, very funny at times, and the evidence in the audience was that women liked it enormously. And Patty Duke, as Natalie, supplies a wonderful performance.


Roger Ebert: http://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/me-natalie-1969

"Our free range days are over."
Fr. Pearse J. Harman-Ultraviolet (1998)

reply

"... an artificial mess of wisecracks and sentimentality"
-Vincent Canby
NY Times 7/14/1969
what else does Canby say about it?

Duke speaks of her difficulty getting this made: a suicide attempt during production due to (anger) bipolar, and trivia says confrontation with Fred Coe (her collaborator on the Miracle Worker) over the choice of ending.

I wonder if her mental-state affected her performance (despite a GG win), and related effects that held the film from better exposure. Fred Coe may have been indifferent by this point.

reply

How did Patti want the movie to end?

reply

It uses an awful lot of voice-over exposition (the sign of a weak screenplay).

But if you're prone to sentimentality (or ever felt the feelings Natalie is going through), then it's still worth 2 hours.

reply

I saw it myself late on a Saturday night on my local station. At that time, the station aired movies on Saturday nights at 10:30 (and were sponsored by a local now-defunct carpeting business). Anyhow, it was not too bad a movie; I liked the fact that Natalie was independent and out on her own, with nothing holding her back.

reply

I saw this film one late morning on TBS when I was a teenager. I just wanted to see Al Pacino, (only a minute he was in the film) but I fell in love with the story. It's kind of emotional. There's always hope for everyone to be loved.

"SG"

reply

As a movie- it was O.K. The lead character was, well, not overly likable. I guess they were showing her flaws ?

The make-up to make Patty look "ugly" looks rather comical and is a little off-putting.


But as a (now) period piece..it's great! I like the whole look of the movie and like many others I am obsessed by what NYC looked like in the 1960s. Loved her apartment ! (I think her rent was like $25.00 a week or something).


The scene with Salome Jens as a "stripper" in her dressing room is several minutes of; what should have been an Oscar winner. It's just one of those scenes you don't forget.
There is an incredible look inside a REAL pharmacy in Staten Island. If you are old enough to remember - no CVS or Walgreens back in the day. LOL.

And how handsome was James Farrentino ?







"In every dimension , there's another YOU!"

reply

Who did he play?

reply