MovieChat Forums > Le vieil homme et l'enfant (1968) Discussion > Was the old man really a racist?

Was the old man really a racist?


Every item I've read about this film makes the claim that the old man is
an anti-Semitic bigot. Yet his comments about the Jews being responsible for
the war, the various negative physical descriptions about Jews, etc. suggest
that he's basically a product of ignorance, not a true bigot. He probably
doesn't know what a Jew is; he's just parroting propaganda he's heard on the
radio broadcasts to which he faithfully listens.
Doesn't he figure out, eventually, that Claude is Jewish? If he really were
a racist, wouldn't he reject the little boy? The remark that he makes to
Claude at the end of the film seems to be kind of an apology for his earlier
remarks.

I'm not crying, you fool, I'm laughing!

reply

I agree with you. I've watched the film a few times now in the past week and have been trying to pick up on the subtle themes it presents in the side stories.
I figure that an anti-semitic mentality wasn't as uncommon in Europe before the war as we might think today. Also, Pepe's racism is mixed with his nationalism (he is anti-English as well as Anti-Russian), and a little class-ism (his comments about his Red daughter, and how the little guy gets the shaft).
These comments are harmless as they are not backed up with actions and ultimately in the end of the film I believe that Pepe begins to let them go due to France's liberation (now he has the Americans to complain about). Pepe is not a true racist but rather a common old man who at heart is kind, but still talks big when it comes to old jadedness.

reply

In my view, ignorance is mostly the basis for racism. People who are interested in the other side of a story, curious and ready to get deeper into a theme will be less apt to be racist.

reply

@ zoostation7, I agree w/ everything, except the comments being harmless bit.
Had it been a different child, it could have been very damaging, but as it stands
it's one of my favorite films, that should be included in school curriculum worldwide.
It embodies the power of words/ propaganda and the power of love/humor.

reply

The OP confusing cause with effect. Whatever the cause of the old man's bigotry, the effect is that he's a bigot.

reply