MovieChat Forums > Twisted Nerve (1969) Discussion > Downs Syndrome Controversy - protestors ...

Downs Syndrome Controversy - protestors have a point


The film was very controversial when released in the UK in late 1968 due to its alleged linking of mongolism and psychopathy. There was some attempt to get it banned although it was never cut by the BBFC. As a result of the controversy, the producers were forced to add a voice-over at the beginning of the film (which is on the DVD).

Having watched the film, I think the protesters have a point. The screenplay would stand on its own as a study of a sociopath without the need for Martin to have a Mongol brother at all - who throws a ball violently at Martin as he walks away thus implying that Mongols are violent/psychotic - or imply, as it clearly does, that if you give birth to someone with Downs syndrome, your next child is more likely to be a psychopath ("Oh dear, oh dear" says the doctor when told about this). The camera also focuses on the Downs Syndrome chromosone after Martin kills a victim thus associating one with t'other.

reply

'Throws a ball violently'? He threw the ball because he didn't want his brother to leave. I didn't understand the need for the Down's syndrome scenes in the context of the screenplay (except shock value) but at no time did I think Down's Syndrome = psychopath. It's like the protests for The Tenant, Cruising and The Silence of the Lambs.

reply